Dailymaverick logo

Maverick News

This article is more than a year old

Maverick News

Ramaphosa axes Simelane as justice minister — but keeps her in the Cabinet

The President has moved Thembi Simelane in a late-night Cabinet reshuffle, appointing her to the Human Settlements portfolio. This comes more than three months after he had requested a report from Simelane regarding her dubious dealings with VBS Mutual Bank.
Ramaphosa axes Simelane as justice minister — but keeps her in the Cabinet

President Cyril Ramaphosa reconfigured his Government of National Unity (GNU) Cabinet on Tuesday night, announcing that Thembi Simelane would take over as minister of human settlements.

In a statement on Tuesday evening, Presidency spokesperson Vincent Magwenya said Simelane would be replaced by Mmamoloko Kubayi as minister of justice and constitutional development.

The move, Magwenya said, “was to ensure the effectiveness of [the] Cabinet in delivering to its mandate and in accordance with section 91(2) of the Constitution”.

Simelane has increasingly come under fire after a Daily Maverick and News24 investigation in August revealed that in 2016, Simelane received a “loan” from a company that had brokered investments with VBS Mutual Bank.

Read more: Thembi Simelane’s date with destiny will ripple through GNU, EFF, MK and the entire justice system

Simelane used a “commercial loan” of R575,600 from Gundo Wealth Solutions, owned by Ralliom Razwinane, to purchase a coffee shop in Sandton.

Simelane was the mayor of Polokwane Municipality in 2016, when she received the loan and when the municipality unlawfully invested R349-million in VBS, which was brokered by Razwinane. (Razwinane is on trial for fraud, corruption and money laundering for his role as a commission agent connecting municipalities, including Polokwane Municipality, with VBS.)

Read more: Revealed: Simelane’s VBS-linked coffee shop ‘loan agreement’ likely backdated

When VBS was put under administration in March 2018, forensic investigators found it had rewarded Razwinane with kickbacks totalling R24.2-million for being a commissioning agent for various municipalities and state entities through corrupt transactions and contraventions of the Municipal Finance Management Act.



On Tuesday, Daily Maverick and News24 revealed that Simelane lived an extravagant lifestyle in 2018, while she was still mayor of Polokwane, when she spent 569% more than her known annual income. This was less than two years after Simelane had taken the R575,600 “loan” from Gundo Wealth Solutions to pay for a coffee shop in Sandton.

Mounting pressure


Following the allegations contained in Daily Maverick and News24’s exposé, Ramaphosa requested a detailed report and meeting with Simelane in August, over her dealings with VBS Mutual Bank. The President has been under mounting pressure to act against Simelane after the allegations came to light.

Demands for Simelane to respond to the allegations came in thick and fast from all quarters. As justice minister, Simelane oversaw the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), which is investigating and prosecuting those involved in the looting and collapse of VBS.

The DA and ActionSA repeatedly labelled Simelane’s position as justice minister a conflict of interest and called for her to account before Parliament. The EFF said Simelane must resign in the face of the revelations that she received more than half a million rand from an organisation that brokered unlawful investments with VBS.

Appearing before Parliament’s justice committee in September, however, Simelane was adamant that there was nothing untoward about the private loan of R575,600 she received from VBS.

On Tuesday night, DA MP and spokesperson on justice and constitutional development, advocate Glynnis Breytenbach, said Ramaphosa’s redeployment of Simelane was “short-sighted and disrespectful” to South Africa.

“While the President has finally addressed the untenable conflict of interest of having a minister of justice accused of corruption, his decision to simply move her somewhere else does not address the underlying issue — she stands accused of corruption and is subject to investigations. Human Settlements is a vital department for providing housing to South Africans. It must be led by a credible individual.

“The indecisiveness of the President, who has explicitly committed to fighting corruption, is especially shocking and quite blatantly insincere,” said Breytenbach.

In his light Cabinet reshuffle, Ramaphosa also appointed Phumzile Mgcina, who was serving as the deputy minister for labour and employment, as the deputy minister of mineral and petroleum resources. Judith Nemadzinga-Tshabalala was appointed as the deputy minister of employment and labour. DM

Comments

Scotty84 Dec 3, 2024, 10:28 PM

ANC supporters are aghast, her positions should be terminated immediately. This is a "weak response" and needs a firmer response, she should held accountable to Parliament.

Steve Davidson Dec 4, 2024, 06:44 AM

ANC supporters are responsible for keeping these crooks in power so for them to be 'aghast' has to be one of the most stupid words we've heard describe them! All they want to do is get their own snouts in the same trough, but nothing else.

Scotty84 Dec 4, 2024, 08:23 AM

Aghast means "shock and horror" what else should any thinking person think or allude to? No need to get your snout in the trough, rather stand back and watch events as they unfold.

Scotty84 Dec 4, 2024, 08:25 AM

No snout in the trough for me !!

Kevin Venter Dec 4, 2024, 01:54 AM

OMG! This is like getting a flat wheel on a car and then applying the solution of swapping it with a wheel from the other side. The citizens of this country seriously need to wake up. Cyril Ramaphosa just showed the country that he is no better than Jacob Zuma, in fact he is cut from the same cloth.

jsiebrits Dec 4, 2024, 06:00 AM

The best the Prez could come up with, after using the time and space he asked for?

Kevin Venter Dec 4, 2024, 06:52 AM

Yip, many masters that he has to appease behind the scenes or risk an all out faction war within the ANC. The looters want to keep looting so there better not be any accountability that starts to happen. "ANC ranked 16th most corrupt organisation out of 7,000 worldwide" is not by accident.

virginia crawford Dec 4, 2024, 03:40 PM

Or stabbing another tyre to even things out.

Kevin Venter Dec 4, 2024, 02:01 AM

The ANC clearly has no intention of stopping the theft, instead, continue to condone it and protect the guilty. Tax payers money will STILL be used to pay this morally devoid person. The ONLY acceptable action is for her to be REMOVED from government, investigated and for justice to be served.

Kevin Venter Dec 4, 2024, 02:25 AM

"..untenable conflict of interest of having a minister of justice accused of corruption" - Err, moving her to human settlements now suddenly makes her less corrupt? It is an untenable conflict of interest to have ANY minister accused of corruption!! The depth of this stupidity knows no limits.

imvu Dec 4, 2024, 05:20 AM

DM giving credit to CR? Why call it axing? The term "Axes" creates the impression CR is holding her accountable. But we cant say that when she is just given another portfolio

Kevin Venter Dec 4, 2024, 06:13 AM

Exactly! Should read Simelane rewarded by being redeployed to Human Settlements. She clearly then had some influence behind the scenes for the NPA to drop the Phala Phala investigation, and for that, reward is due.

Pierre Durand Dec 4, 2024, 05:26 AM

The wheels on the bus go......

cracklin62 Dec 4, 2024, 07:57 AM

Alternatively the good ship SS Plunder sails on

Lian van den Heever Dec 4, 2024, 06:03 AM

And so the taxpayer is paying foran even bigeger bloated cabinet

onceoffaddre Dec 4, 2024, 06:09 AM

Why can this man not make a single (1... ONE!!!!) decision that shows he has a spine? Just one! How did he even make it in business! Oh, wait... now I remember.

Tim Bester Dec 4, 2024, 07:41 AM

Maybe he has no spine?

cracklin62 Dec 4, 2024, 08:00 AM

Or balls. Or anything. Only good for offall

Cobuswelgemoed Dec 4, 2024, 08:24 AM

Offal without any balls???

Wilhelm Boshoff Dec 4, 2024, 06:23 AM

The revolving cadre corruption door.

Laurence Erasmus Dec 4, 2024, 06:48 AM

2026 is around the corner. Voters will have to show their balls and get rid of the scum as Cyril clearly doesn’t have the balls to do so. Another election bloodbath loading for the corrupt ANC!

Kevin Venter Dec 4, 2024, 07:00 AM

The ANC didn't lose votes to the DA and FF+, it was to MK. The majority of voters will rather vote for MK (along racial lines) than for accountability and responsible governance, regardless of the consequences. I can only hope the voters wake up in a hurry and we do see a shift in voting pattern.

onceoffaddre Dec 4, 2024, 02:50 PM

This is true. There has never been a protest against corruption in SA. People don't actually realize! Protests have been along the lines of "You can't eat that stolen loot alone... share". Even the definition of "Service Delivery Protest" is just a euphemism for "Demands for free stuff".

Trenton Carr Dec 4, 2024, 12:01 PM

Tribes, ever was and will be, too many tribes.

Roke Wood Dec 4, 2024, 06:50 AM

Poor reflection of what is happening at the highest echelons of our government. Moving her to a different position in cabinet is worse. It shows lack of insight, foresight, lack of accountability and integrity. However we must be mindful that these are allegations, not yet proven in court.

Kevin Venter Dec 4, 2024, 07:05 AM

Even if there is evidence, do you think it will ever be proven in court? How many cases have conveniently been "dropped" by the NPA? Innocent until proven guilty of course, as per the constitution, but her bs answers to blunt questions are enough to point to guilt in the court of public opinion.

Alan Watkins Dec 4, 2024, 09:03 AM

If it came down to sufficient evidence that could be proven in court, then mnay senior ANC leaders would be in prison already. But we have a situation where the NPA are the gatekeepers on getting anything into court

Cachunk Dec 4, 2024, 07:17 AM

Probably the weakest, most pathetic “decision” this spineless moron has ever made and there is some stiff competition.

Karl Sittlinger Dec 4, 2024, 07:25 AM

It's the ANC way to protect their cadre thieves. There really is no other way to see this. And DM actually nominated CR as person of the year.

Cachunk Dec 4, 2024, 07:27 AM

So cyril has admitted that she is too corrupt for Justice, but just corrupt enough for Human Settlements. This absolute final proof that corruption is tolerated in the disgusting anc.

Graeme de Villiers Dec 4, 2024, 02:42 PM

Trappe van vercorruption

Rodshep Dec 4, 2024, 07:28 AM

Cyrils amazing back bone for all to see, not axed and put to pasture pending an orange suite but moved to another portfolio. Human settlements some of the poorest of the poor, and she walses around Europe with a 30,000 rand backpack. We're did the money come from..????

Ifitwalkslikeaduck P Dec 4, 2024, 07:50 AM

agree, now time to track that cash back to its source and put a bunch of people in orange jumpsuits. If there was every a reason to pay for journalism in this country this type of investigation and outcome is it.

Relentless One Dec 4, 2024, 07:57 AM

CRIMINALS will always protect their fellow CRIMINALS. I've always wondered how much Cyril benefitted from VBS????

Gareth Dickens Dec 4, 2024, 08:09 AM

S&P and Fitch raised SA credit rating from stable to positive within 3 months of each other. Moody's+ Fitch+S&P just bumped Eskom up to positive. These are qualitative assessments of the country's prospects. Things are getting better. Will the cadres get the credit? Where is the good news?

Angus Walsh Dec 4, 2024, 08:16 AM

Doesn’t sum up what Ramaphosa thinks about the department of human settlement, it sums up what he thinks about blatant corruption and whether it should mean if you get caught you will be punished - apparently not. You get sent in a ‘ paid holiday’ until everyone forgets you are a criminal.

Mazamban. Dec 4, 2024, 08:21 AM

The pigs shuffle around the trough

Mike Pragmatist Dec 4, 2024, 08:26 AM

Not an unexpected response, from the most indecisive "president" imaginable. Like a marionette his responses come after the squabble between the 3 year olds to pull on the strings has been completed.

Y3mmxiii Mnguni Dec 4, 2024, 09:05 AM

South Africa currently lacks a strong and charismatic leader at the helm. Instead, it seems we're settling for mediocrity, which leaves much to be desired in terms of bold governance and inspiring vision.

ttshililo2 Dec 4, 2024, 10:29 AM

We don’t need a charismatic leader. We just need a competent leader with a backbone who is willing to stand up for the truth- alas, these days even that seems to be quixotic.

Middle aged Mike Dec 4, 2024, 11:02 AM

South Africa lacks an electorate who make rational choices based on their best interests. Our 'leaders', most especially the one with the dollary couch are merely a symptom of that.

virginia crawford Dec 4, 2024, 03:43 PM

Like Hilary Clinton's deplorables? That got her the vote (not).

Ga g Dec 4, 2024, 09:44 AM

I am worried that any improvements made by having the DA in the GNU will simply be passed off by the ANC as themselves being responsible for those improvements. ANC has time again shown it is incompetent, and CR is corrupt as all of them. Maybe the DA should pull out of the GNU.

Trenton Carr Dec 4, 2024, 10:05 AM

Ramaspineless must be reeeeeally scared of her to keep giving her taxpayer funds to keep shut up.

A Rosebank Ratepayer Dec 4, 2024, 10:29 AM

It’s much more complex. ANC corrupt faction would love DA to withdraw. ANC centre would no longer hold. Zim is run by 1000 corrupt elites who use the electorate only as voting fodder every 4 years. MK + ANC/MK sleepers (50%) would love to be in that position. DA helping to keep things honest.

Hilary Morris Dec 4, 2024, 10:42 AM

Oh! My! God! He has no shame, but what is worse is the middle finger shown to the entire world. Does he think stupidity is endemic? And this is the man who is head of the G20. It's beyond comprehension.

Enver Klein Dec 4, 2024, 10:48 AM

Very sad that her sister, Nokuthula, died fighting for justice and liberation. Thembi is a disgrace to her family and the liberation movement. "The TRC heard that Nokuthula, was kidnapped while on a mission in Johannesburg in 1983; she was never seen alive again; her fate remains a mystery".

Middle aged Mike Dec 4, 2024, 11:05 AM

We aren't short of are disgraces to the memories of the people who gave their lives in liberating SA. Ramaphosas gang is replete with them.

D'Esprit Dan Dec 4, 2024, 11:07 AM

Great. Mmamoloko Kubayi illegally fired a staff member because she (Kubayi) got stuck in a lift and her husband got a dodgy R11m tender. Just who you want heading the justice department.

Walter Spatula Dec 4, 2024, 11:10 AM

Apparently having a crook heading Human Settlements looks fine to Ramaphosa.

Mark Penwarden Dec 4, 2024, 11:17 AM

That is the ANC way, don't fire someone cause they're not doing their job or potentially corrupt, just move them into another position.

abuchan Dec 4, 2024, 11:45 AM

The Fox has been placed to guard the chicken coop. Mr President you know what to do ! Fire Her in the name of everything sanctified. The shenanigans will NEVER stop . More housing tenders going to be tainted .

Maj.kno Dec 4, 2024, 01:38 PM

I believe its the first of many to come with the current over-bloated cabinet in olace.

virginia crawford Dec 4, 2024, 03:39 PM

Always with the half measures.

Gugu1 K Dec 4, 2024, 05:57 PM

Did CR reshuffle Simelane as a means of the acting upon the report she submitted to him after the first VBS corruption-links allegations were made against her or did he reshuffle her for the purported reasons outlined in the press statement yesterday?

Ian Wallace Wallace Dec 4, 2024, 07:28 PM

So zero sanction then? Same salary, same perks, same access to diverting public funds. I do not however feel bad for the 67% of the public that voted for some or other variant of the ANC or did not vote at all. Wholescale theft of everything not nailed down was clearly the choice they made.

Ritey roo roo Dec 4, 2024, 10:12 PM

some things never change. same old same old. shame on you ramaposeur

Ken Randell Dec 5, 2024, 10:59 AM

A decision almost as bad as Zuma's sacking the then minister of Finance and appointing Des van Rooyen - the week-end wonder. And that was apparently reversed with some pressure from Ramaphosa and others. But now he plays from exactly the same hymn book. Mandela was a statesman -no one else left.

D'Esprit Dan Dec 5, 2024, 07:01 PM

Ramaphosa didn't axe her - he spinelessly shuffled her sideways. Pathetic.