Dailymaverick logo

South Africa

This article is more than a year old

South Africa

The Zuma playbook — He’s appealing against ANC expulsion as part of plan to become president again

The MK leader is exploiting growing ANC discomfort at Ramaphosa’s close relationship with big business.  
The Zuma playbook — He’s appealing against ANC expulsion as part of plan to become president again

Expelled by the ANC on Friday, Umkhonto Wesizwe (MK) party leader and former head of state Jacob Zuma took a day to state his true intention: to take back the ANC.

In an interview in the Sunday Times, Zuma said: “When we were establishing the MK party – we met as black parties … and agreed that we are going to take over … it’s something that happened.” 

On Friday, 22 November, the ANC national disciplinary appeals committee, headed by Johnny de Lange, Soviet Lekganyane and Noxolo Kiviet, upheld Zuma’s expulsion. This ended an affiliation that started when Zuma joined the ANC at 17 – he is now 82. 

“Mr Zuma’s behaviour exemplifies the highest form of ill-discipline and a direct assault on the historical mission of the ANC. By establishing and leading a rival political party, he abandoned the core values of organisational loyalty and collective accountability, converting himself into a tool for destabilisation,” the party said.

“His [Zuma’s] actions have undermined the unity and cohesion of the movement at a time when it is critical to consolidate and push forward with organisational renewal and confront South Africa’s pressing challenges. This decision must serve as a reminder that no individual is greater than the movement.”

A day after the ANC issued its statement, the Jacob Zuma Foundation responded: “President Zuma strongly rejects the notion that the ANC under the leadership of President Cyril Ramaphosa has the authority to expel him from a movement to which he has dedicated his life.”

He will appeal to the party’s national executive committee and possibly sue the ANC as part of Zuma’s lawfare strategy – fighting political battles in court – which he excels at. This is part of MK’s plan to reverse into the ANC and take over, a strategy made clear by the weekend interview in the Sunday Times. Veteran members such as Zuma see the ANC as family, and you can’t be expelled from kin.  

This strategy is neither far-fetched nor impossible. President Cyril Ramaphosa has more than 1,000 days before becoming a lame-duck leader when his term as party president ends. Zuma and MK target this date as an opportunity to prosecute the reunification of black-led and liberation movement parties, where the MK party now situates itself. 

An analyst who has worked with Zuma says the former president believes only a Nguni person can lead the ANC, and that Ramaphosa has sold out to capital. This is because of the outsized role that big business plays in the state. The CEO initiative has helped Ramaphosa eliminate the political liability that load-shedding has become and promises a second phase that could crack the growth and job problem, but the political cost is high. Zuma is exploiting unhappiness within the ANC at Ramaphosa’s relationship with capital to stage a defiance campaign against his expulsion. This will build the sleeper community of MK supporters in the ANC, such as Tony Yengeni, who is the public face of a constituency in the ANC that also supports MK. 

“Both Zuma and [former President] Thabo [Mbeki] feel Cyril is destroying the ANC. They believe the ANC needs to take back power but that there is no plan to re-establish the dominance of the ANC,” said the analyst, who cannot be quoted publicly. There is continuing concern by the ANC that it is being outflanked by Democratic Alliance ministers in the Government of National Unity (GNU) Cabinet and by new leaders such as Sports, Arts and Culture Minister Gayton McKenzie of the Patriotic Alliance.
graphic showing MK support

This scenario document summary shows that black party unity surfaced as the ANC met to shape power agreements after the seismic loss it suffered in the May 2024 election. This scenario was popular but ultimately did not win the day as the party chose the GNU, which now governs South Africa through a partnership with the DA and eight other parties. 

Within the Tripartite Alliance, the GNU remains unpopular, and the South African Communist Party (SACP) is leading an intra-alliance campaign against it. This week, the ANC goes into talks with its communist ally to deal with its growing public concerns about the direction of the GNU. Cosatu leader Zingiswa Losi has indicated that Cosatu is also opposed to South Africa’s macro-economic policies under Ramaphosa, even though she is his staunch ally. 

The ANC in Gauteng is publicly opposed to the GNU, as are other provinces that feel the power-sharing agreement is diminishing the party. Zuma wants to tap into this thickening vein of opposition, and he will treat his expulsion as illegitimate.

In his nine-page letter to explain his jump to MK, Dali Mpofu sets out the plan for black unity he carved in secret meetings over two years. 

“I have been part of the conceptualisation, formation, announcement and protection, if not the very continued existence of uMkhonto Wesizwe,” he wrote. “I can reveal that for the best part of 12 months between January and December 2023, we held a series of critical two-person engagements, which were later expanded to a very limited number of other leaders and persons. These underground meetings took place in the provinces of KwaZulu-Natal and later on in Gauteng.

“Within the next five years, we need to put all our collective energies and focus on the sacred mission to reunite the forces of African liberation in South Africa, whatever it takes. The so-called GNU must be fought, defeated and dismantled. By any lawful means necessary,” Mpofu wrote.

The letter sets out the MK strategy and shows that by refusing to accept the legitimacy of his expulsion from the ANC, Zuma has fired the starting gun on its rollout. 

MK was the story of the May 2024 election: it won 14.6% of the vote, the highest ever for a start-up party. And it took those votes from the ANC, pushing the party to a 40.2% defeat; it also cut support for the EFF down to 9.5% and forced the red berets into fourth position while party leader Julius Malema had bet on being in second position. 

With former EFF deputy president Floyd Shivambu, who joined the MK party as national organiser, being appointed as secretary-general, a decisive role, at the weekend, MK announced that Joe Ndhlela will replace him as the national organiser. Ndhlela, reportedly a convicted fraudster, was with the Patriotic Alliance but quit in November 2023. DM

Comments

Jon Quirk Nov 24, 2024, 10:18 PM

Unless and until Jacob Zuma and his acolytes are charged with treason, and convicted for his clear leading and fomenting of his treasonous acts in July, 2021, this issue will not be resolved. Ramaphosa, over to you; cojones are required and now.

MaverickMe Nov 25, 2024, 04:14 PM

Why does JZ just not rename himself while he is at ? Jacob Gedleyihlekisa Hitler Stalin Zedong Leopold Pot Jong-Un Putin Trump Zuma AK-XLVII

Hilary Morris Nov 25, 2024, 06:54 PM

Mostly because he couldn't spell it?

100victim Nov 25, 2024, 08:38 PM

Are you suggesting that a sitting president should give the NPA directive on who it should prosecute? That will be lawfare & ground for impeachment. Its a tinderbox for ANC at 40%. You have to be mindful who has deep networks and loyalties with State Security Agency.

Lesley e Nov 26, 2024, 07:15 AM

Zuma is already charged with corruption. The big question is whether the NPA can find a judge who has enough backbone to end the Stalingrad tactics and ensure that Zuma faces those charges. If not we'd better all start figuring out ways, as horrific as the thought is, of packing for Perth

roelf.pretorius Nov 25, 2024, 03:45 AM

According to the SA Constitution Jacob Zuma can't be elected as the State President again, because he has already been elected to the position twice, which is the maximum allowed.

Henry Henry Nov 25, 2024, 07:55 AM

LOL.... His aim is precisely to overthrow the constitutional state.

Pierre Mare Nov 25, 2024, 01:01 PM

just like Trump

Kanu Sukha Nov 26, 2024, 12:22 AM

What I said to a person enquiring what 'things' will look/be like after 4 more years of Trump ! He plans to be president for life .. and at a rally frankly told the faithful cult members that they would 'not need to vote again' ! How more 'upfront' than that can you get ?

100victim Nov 25, 2024, 08:28 PM

The man will be 83 in a few months, the only person who had capacity & electoral numbers to change the constitution was one Thabo Mbeki. Only President with 2/3 majority. JZ is only playing the long game to buy himself cover from his legal woes & as a by product build his legacy. Survival is #1

Patterson Alan John Nov 25, 2024, 04:06 AM

I wrote an opinion for my overseas family, many months before the last elections, warning that Zuma was being under-estimated. He has moles in the ANC, knows their strategies and will turn on the ANC. Who replaces the hesitant Ramaphosa? Zuma will be back! Everyone should be scared - very scared.

paulbarnett Nov 25, 2024, 07:49 AM

Stop peddling fear. Zuma shouldn't be underestimated, but he can't return as president—the Constitution forbids it. We overcame apartheid and ousted Zuma before. Tax revolts would erupt if he tried. His failed push for a "black unity government" shows he's on the back foot. Calm down

Lucifer's Consiglieri Nov 25, 2024, 12:02 PM

They don’t regard the constitution as an impediment. They specifically target replacing it.

100victim Nov 25, 2024, 08:44 PM

How will he replace it? He failed to change the constitution when he had some healthy support in parliament and now with 15% you think he will achieve what he failed to do when he had over 60% & capacity to strike a deal to get 2/3rds? These are just political games to keep the masses hypnotized.

Skinyela Nov 26, 2024, 06:20 AM

Zuma does not want to amend the constitution, he wants to scrap it altogether. For that he doesn't need 2/3s majority, he needs a popular revolt or a coup. For a successful revolt he doesn't necessarily need to be backed by the majority.

BillyBumhe Nov 25, 2024, 09:12 AM

He will be 87 by the time of the next election. Might even (fingers crossed) be dead. His time is nearly over. And his party will not outlive him.

Walter Spatula Nov 25, 2024, 06:12 PM

That might be best, but i really want him to die in jail for ruining literally tens of millions of lives.

Skinyela Nov 25, 2024, 06:41 AM

So much information-peddling and tribalism by this 'source' whose identity is conveniently withheld. And free airtime for the likes of Dali Mpofu to spread their propaganda. DM slowly, but surely becoming another IOL(Iqbal's rag)

ttshililo2 Nov 25, 2024, 07:35 AM

I agree with the 1st part of your comment: ‘tribalism’ has been stoked by likes of Zille & of course J.Z, it’s a non-starter really. At its infancy, in the late 19th century, the founders of the liberation movement realised the divide and rule tactic of tribalism- this they put to bed early.

Grumpy Old Man Nov 25, 2024, 07:44 AM

The only way a Zuma, reverse engineering, strategy would work is if ANC structures were comprised of self-serving, self-interested, short-sighted and morally bankrupt individuals - and if the ANC did not have an existing pool of strong, talented, beyond reproach leaders ready to step up to the plate

Donal Slemon Nov 25, 2024, 06:50 PM

Ooh, satire - love it. See what you did there.

Michael Smith Nov 25, 2024, 07:58 AM

The thing about being South African is that you just *know* this all about access to patronage networks. The butthurt ex-cadres are probably running low on cash by now, and need to re-up. Tragic end to a country with such immense potential, hijacked by thugs.

Henry Henry Nov 25, 2024, 07:58 AM

Excellent piece by Haffejee. A look at the thinking and strategy behind the scenes. Rare to find a gem like this these days!

John P Nov 25, 2024, 08:10 AM

Is it not time that the Communist Party tested it's support at the polls instead of sitting comfy and influencing the ANC as it has always done?

Lesley e Nov 26, 2024, 07:22 AM

Couldn't agree more. Has always baffled me that political parties work in alliance. How strong is their constituency? And which would trade unions favour?

Michael Ash Nov 25, 2024, 08:30 AM

I am keenly awaiting the terminus of a terminally ill person.

berneleuvennink Nov 25, 2024, 09:07 AM

"Black party unity..." Are we doing this now, seriously?

William Kelly Nov 25, 2024, 09:10 AM

Will never happen. He's too old and too sickly to last much longer - the sharks are already in the water around him and swimming. Once he ceases to be their meal ticket they'll pounce, in much the same way as I suspect Juju is about to find out. No taxpayer monies under your control, no power.

100victim Nov 25, 2024, 08:47 PM

Hear! hear!

R S Nov 25, 2024, 09:11 AM

Firstly, Zuma is an old man. Once he's gone MK will tear itself apart. Secondly, MK will most likely just be more daggers into the already wounded and dying ANC so there won't be anything to reclaim. Zuma is not the ANC.

100victim Nov 25, 2024, 08:52 PM

Correct, MKP as currently constituted will not survive post Zuma. They have imported the seeds of its destruction by having this confederacy of the walking wounded. The glue that brings all these disparate groupings together is JZ. ANC will continue to be largest party albeit with less than 50%.

brintonclements Nov 25, 2024, 09:16 AM

This is so typical of African leadership. The focus on party politics must always overshadow the potential benefits of united and collaborative political systems. Many leaders appear more driven by the pursuit of power than by a genuine commitment to improving the wellbeing of their people.

100victim Nov 25, 2024, 08:56 PM

What is happening in USA with rise of Trumpism or in West Europe with the rise of the far right? What is happening in official one party states in Asia and Euro-Asia? Its a humanity issue. The price of freedom is eternal vigilance. Any country, any people are susceptible as we see it playing out.

Walter Spatula Nov 25, 2024, 10:12 AM

"Black unity" has never existed anywhere in history, and I doubt it's suddenly going to emerge now.

Grumpy Old Man Nov 25, 2024, 10:55 AM

If someone suggested to me that I should think or vote a particular way because of my skin pigmentation or background I would be a tad angry. It's the worst kind of insult to suggest to anyone they do not have the freedom or right, to formulate own opinion. Viva the Revolution

Johan Buys Nov 25, 2024, 01:40 PM

“Black party” is used several times in the article. Since when is race a strategy? There are, within black persons, radically different politics, economics and values. If only Nguni counts, what happens to the other black ‘tribes’, coloreds, whites, asian citizens?

Fernando Moreira Nov 25, 2024, 02:11 PM

The reverse take-over of the ANC in plain sight !

miker Nov 25, 2024, 02:37 PM

What really upsets me, is that the ANC expel this guy, only after he "damages" the party and not when there was very obvious corruption, state capture, contempt of court, rape accusations. Self serving joke of a party.

Skinyela Nov 25, 2024, 02:54 PM

He was in charge of the said party at the time, he and his loyalists were the ANC and the ANC was them.

Les Thorpe Nov 25, 2024, 02:45 PM

Old Zupta at it again. If his cat had kittens, he would appeal!! A symptom of S.A.'s criminal justice system where no one bothers with "the law", every forth person has been arrested and is out on bail, and trials take upwards of twenty years.

MAC Jones Nov 25, 2024, 03:27 PM

MK will live as a long as Zuma lives, and indications are, he isn't very well. The ANC has no real successor who can win an election, all the big liberation names have been spent and the EFF is declining...

Kanu Sukha Nov 26, 2024, 12:13 AM

" he isn't very well. " .. in the head you mean ?

Louise Wilkins Nov 25, 2024, 05:44 PM

Groan. Someone please take Zuma out.

Colin Braude Nov 25, 2024, 07:20 PM

What this Shelley Garland analysis misses is that the JZ783ers tried rolling mass action, which worked so well against apartheid, in July 2021 and it failed because those dependent upon the shopping mall economy resisted it, acting out of economic, rather than racial class interest

khoza Jan 12, 2025, 09:01 AM

As for Zuma being a president again, forget it. Even in the unlikely event that his party were to win the elections next week, the very people he is sharing the stage with at the moment, will make sure they push so far out of the way, he won't be found anytime soon again.