Dailymaverick logo

Business Maverick

This article is more than a year old

Business Maverick

Customs duties: taxing times for Shein and Temu shoppers

If you shop at Shein and Temu, you face increased costs due to new tax regulations from SARS, intended to create a level playing field for local retailers. Here’s what you need to know.
Customs duties: taxing times for Shein and Temu shoppers

Online shopping in South Africa has just become more expensive. SARS has introduced new tax regulations for imports from foreign online platforms, aiming to protect local industries and generate revenue. These changes affect consumers and retailers alike, with revised customs duties, import VAT and de minimus rule changes.

Read more: Better late than never — SARS taxes on Temu, Shein to kick off in September

Taxes up from November


Since November, consumers have been grappling with uncertainty due to recent changes in online shopping taxes. Two regular online shoppers shared their startling experiences.

Wendy Dondolo, a third-year student at Cape Peninsula University of Cape Town, recently incurred a surprising tax and customs fee on her R300 clothing purchase from Shein: “I ordered for R1,300 then my customs were R500 … that’s almost 50%.”

Dondolo’s previous strategy was splitting orders to minimise customs fees, but she now doubts its effectiveness. “Normally the strategy was to split your order into two orders to pay less customs but now I don’t think the strategy will work because you are still going to pay more customs even if you split your order,” she told Daily Maverick.

Read more: The Temu online shopping app fuss – a user review and safety tips

Similarly, Nwabisa Gocini, who has been helping her neighbours with online shopping free of charge, has experienced significant challenges recently.

“Yoh! Customs are now expensive, I recently ordered for another lady for a few items amounting to R1,2oo but she was taxed R400. I ordered for someone else for R958 and her tax was over R200. The tax is so high and purchased items arrive very late,” she said.

Customs duties


This surge in customs fees is no isolated incident. In fact, it’s a direct result of South Africa’s revised taxation process for imports from foreign online platforms.

The taxation process for imports from foreign online platforms involves several key stages, starting with customs duties, which are taxes imposed on imported goods to protect local industries and generate revenue for the government. These duties are calculated based on their type, value and origin.

Read more: Don’t be fooled by shopping platform Temu’s childlike interface

Chetan Vanmali, partner in tax: indirect (VAT and customs) at Webber Wentzel, says product categories, such as clothing, jewellery, home goods and sports equipment are classified under distinct customs tariff codes, each falling within specific chapters. As a result, each category may incur varying amounts of duty payable to SARS.

How goods will be taxed


The base for calculating customs duties depends on the customs value of the goods, which is determined according to the World Trade Organization (WTO) Valuation Agreement.

The customs value is typically the transaction value, price paid or payable and may include costs such as freight, insurance, commissions and packaging. The South African Harmonised Customs Tariff determines the customs tariff code (HS code) for imported goods, defining the rate of duty.

The rate of duty is determined based on the tariff classification and can be ad valorem (a percentage of the customs value) or there can be specific duties (a fixed amount per unit, for example per kilogram or litre). 

Raesah Shaik, associate in tax at Webber Wentzel says, for example, clothing items will attract a 40% duty rate. If the purchase price is R1,000, you would pay customs duties of R400.

But wait, there’s more. You would also have to pay import VAT, which works out to R225 for a purchase order of R1,000. So, the total cost would be R1,625.

What changed


Previously, imports under R500 were subject to a 20% customs duty, but exempt from VAT. However, SARS realised that online global retailers were exploiting this exemption. They were also able to undercut local retailers who pay up to 45% customs duty on imports and 15% import VAT.

At the beginning of this month, the de minimis rule was revised so the 20% customs duty will no longer apply. Instead, in line with World Trade Organization (WTO) regulations, applicable import VAT will apply. Beyond import VAT, foreign online retailers that register for VAT would have to charge an additional 15% sales VAT. DM

Comments

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Nov 19, 2024, 06:56 AM

I'm no macro economist, but this sounds very good for South Africans. Yes, there is a direct hit, but it seems to me the indirect economic and planetary benefits will outweigh this.

William Kelly Nov 19, 2024, 07:43 AM

Tariffs and duties hurt local economies far harder then they benefit them. The only beneficiary is government, who, demonstrably, are incapable of administering our taxes at all. Read up on import tariff theory, it's interesting to see which local industries thrive under them.

Rod MacLeod Nov 19, 2024, 08:20 AM

I agree with William. "They were also able to undercut local retailers who pay up to 45% customs duty on imports and 15% import VAT." That tells you a story. You're not protecting any industry, just other local importers at the expense of you, the consumer.

John P Nov 19, 2024, 12:09 PM

It not protect local manufacturers but will level the playing field for local businesses who pay tax including VAT and who employ local people. Shein etc have just been an outflow of Rands with no local benefits other than a low price to the consumer.

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Nov 19, 2024, 07:30 PM

This is exactly my understanding. Also they have been exploiting tax loopholes which provide them an unfair advantage over local businesses, causing local job loss.

laurantsystems Nov 19, 2024, 05:13 PM

Absolutely. All tariffs do, is to prop up manufacturers whose cost structures are not competitive. A Chinese factory that can still compete, in spite of customs duties and tariffs, is clearly more efficient. For this we can blame SA's draconian labour laws.

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Nov 19, 2024, 07:31 PM

Goedkoop can be deurkoop. There are many more aspects to consider than just price.

Johan Buys Nov 19, 2024, 07:37 PM

Laura, refer my post elsewhere. That minimus rule is being abused. No sane importer would place 42 orders for a pressure regulating vale (vs one box with 42) other than for tax and duty evasion. Imagine 42 shoe box size orders vs one apple crate size box with 42. It is beyond silly

Clare Rothwell Nov 20, 2024, 08:46 AM

Have you read about the working conditions of Chinese factory workers, or the environmental impact of fast fashion?

Stu McCro Nov 20, 2024, 02:32 PM

Workers rights and the environment? That's far too woke for her!

Harry Boyle Nov 21, 2024, 10:36 AM

Depeche Mode much!

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Nov 19, 2024, 07:34 PM

These local importers are exactly that. Local. And they employ local people. Our people need employmemt desperately.

ROUX.RIA Nov 20, 2024, 11:33 AM

They are still importers. Just an extra middle man that gets a cut and not contribute to the economy. If it was a local manufacturer, totally different story and I would have supported it.

John P Nov 20, 2024, 12:41 PM

Just extra middle men but expected to supply back up service, showrooms, warranties & more. We have people who demand that we repair/replace their faulty product even though they grey imported the item. Our response is yes we can fix it and charge accordingly or you can return it directly.

johnrwic Nov 20, 2024, 10:05 AM

South Africa’s limited manufacturing has rendered import duties ineffective in supporting industry. Remove tariffs and other taxes, and increase local productivity and innovation in the supply chain to compete against Temu. SARS is the only beneficiary and the consumer worst affected.

Thomas Cleghorn Nov 19, 2024, 08:29 AM

Consumers getting bled again. You gotta love a 'free market economy'!

sharondt12 Nov 19, 2024, 09:37 AM

I ordered 2 kids clothing and stickers for my son's car. R207 and had to pay R169 import duties. That's so unfair. SARS don't hunt illegal trading and gambling on FB. I can point out plenty people who don't pay taxes or paye. To report it to SARS are met with - why you want to ipimpi? Jaaa SARS

Lynda Tyrer Nov 19, 2024, 10:59 AM

Not unfair you order from Amazon USA you always have to pay taxes and custom duties, its nothing new so you first work out if its worth it or not and take a good look at the currency rate at the same time.

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Nov 19, 2024, 07:36 PM

Just because people break the law doesnt mean you are entitled to some form of kickback. And yes, point those people out, I'm sure SARS would love to meet them.

ROUX.RIA Nov 20, 2024, 11:36 AM

Sadly it is too much work for a state official.

Granville Beck Nov 19, 2024, 09:52 AM

Consumers are getting the short end of the stick again. However, even with these increases in Duty, the commodities are still worthwhile to import rather than buying locally. Maybe the local industries should revise margins and be less gready. Gone are the days of +400% markups on local goods.

Ivan van Heerden Nov 19, 2024, 10:05 AM

About time. Both of those platforms practice unfair trade subsidised by the Chinese government. Nett result, lost jobs and sectors in South Africa.

li Nov 19, 2024, 01:32 PM

You have no clue do you. Takealot and Bash buy from China as well and add a 500% markup so their shareholders can get a bigger salary while consumers must suffer. Seriously everything in SA is made in China no matter where you shop. Go look at the labels in your house.

MT Wessels Nov 19, 2024, 10:10 AM

SARS' revenue is completely understandable, it is their purpose regardless of government squander. But high duties to "protect" local businesses is pointless if those goods are not manufactured locally. Shein and Temu simply bypass expensive middlemen like Takealot, not value adders or employers.

Robbed Blind Nov 21, 2024, 11:27 AM

Well said. You can bet that Takealot were behind this change. “Someone think of the poor online retailers!”

Lynda Tyrer Nov 19, 2024, 10:57 AM

Anyone ordering from overseas has had to pay VAT and custom duties on their items, nothing new with this, just catching those trying to "crook" the system. What is bound to happen now is each item will need to be opened and checked which is going to delay deliveries.

John P Nov 19, 2024, 12:03 PM

It is high time this happened. As an importer my company has to pay duties and VAT, why should the consumer not have to pay?

ROUX.RIA Nov 20, 2024, 11:37 AM

Are you adding value to the stuff you import?

John P Nov 20, 2024, 12:46 PM

Yes, knowledge, advice, backup service and support, stock on hand and more. This is not clothing but tech and electronics. My point though is why would it be fair for a company to pay these costs but the consumer does not?

aadil360 Nov 19, 2024, 12:14 PM

The following makes no sense: "But wait, there’s more. You would also have to pay import VAT, which works out to R225 for a purchase order of R1,000. So, the total cost would be R1,625" Why charge VAT on the import duty? The VAT should R150 (15% of R1k), not R225. Just adds more confusion

John P Nov 19, 2024, 12:55 PM

Import VAT is calculated as Customs Value, plus any duty levied on the goods, plus 10 per cent of the Customs Value x 15%. Duties are calculated on the value of the goods PLUS freight costs in the country of export I.E. not the sea or air freight to SA. Customs Value is the actual price charged.

T'Plana Hath Nov 19, 2024, 02:50 PM

Be South African. Buy South African!

laurantsystems Nov 19, 2024, 05:17 PM

Even if buying South African costs more? What you're doing then, in effect, is paying a tax to prop up an uncompetitive SA business and in the process making yourself poorer. That's no way to run an economy. If you want to help local business, vote with your wallet.

Robbed Blind Nov 21, 2024, 11:30 AM

Very few products are produced in South Africa compared to what we need

Ga g Nov 19, 2024, 06:12 PM

About time, I get charged import duties, these Chinese owned and operated platforms should not be exempt.

wardle2066 Nov 20, 2024, 03:27 PM

The textile industry is decimated in SA. Since 1991 it has been in decline due to illegal and unfair trade. This 45% duty, at this time, will only drive prices up. The little Temu imports aren't as big a threat as the container loads and big retail. Too late DTI and SARS .....

ansunelle Nov 21, 2024, 07:50 AM

I honestly feel the tax has been put up too high. Me as a student is already struggling with the current prices of things in SA so I bought on Shein, but with the rise in tax I don't think I will be able to afford it. I understand the point SARS is trying to make but this is quite extreme.

Robbed Blind Nov 21, 2024, 11:34 AM

The headline should have been “Shein and Temu users find out how insane and confiscatory SA’s import tax regime is” SARS charging 50-70% tax on items that can’t be found locally is criminal.