Dailymaverick logo

Maverick News

This article is more than a year old

Maverick News

The woman who refused to be a victim, Alison Botha, fights for her life a second time

The woman who in 1994 survived one of the most vicious gang rapes in South Africa, Alison Botha, needs help.
The woman who refused to be a victim, Alison Botha, fights for her life a second time Alison Botha became a national symbol as one of the first rape survivors publicly to identify herself in South Africa after her attackers, Frans du Toit and Theuns Kruger, abducted and gang raped her in 1994 before repeatedly slitting her throat and disembowelling her. In speaking out, she erased the stigma and shame which surrounded rape at the time, leading many women to suffer in silence across the globe.  https://youtu.be/uQ2Ozd8z2UM [caption id="attachment_2406838" align="alignnone" width="2560"]alison botha fight for life Rape survivor and writer Alison Botha. (Photo: Gallo Images / Sunday Times / Brett Eloff)[/caption] Alison became an international embodiment of resilience and has been the recipient globally of many accolades and awards for her strength. Her assailants had left her for dead on Schoenmakerskop, a remote beach outside Gqeberha (then Port Elizabeth) and her miraculous will to survive led to the publication of her book, I Have Life – Alison’s Journey, which this writer was privileged to have ghostwritten in 1997. [caption id="attachment_2406899" align="alignnone" width="1958"]i have a life Book cover: Facebook[/caption] It went on to be a South African bestseller with more than 95,000 copies sold and went into several reprints to reach millions across the globe. The book has been translated into multiple languages and Alison’s horror and triumph were turned into an award-winning 2016 documentary by Uga Carlini, simply titled Alison. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WIvFTrJGWCY Chris Jansen, the judge who originally sentenced Du Toit (who received three life sentences and Kruger who received one life sentence plus 25 years) said both men should be removed from society “for the rest of their lives”. “I was at the scene where she was assaulted. She crawled naked on a dirt road to the tarmac where she lay down, then two cars stopped by her. The first driver just looked at her like that and then drove off and the second one helped her.” Having left a mutilated Alison for dead, they were surprised to learn during their arrest soon afterwards that she had lived. The two men were buttering bread with the knife they had used to disembowel Alison and were planning to abduct and murder another victim later that day. They were both out on bail for similar offences. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=19tJYqpYWH8&ab_channel=AfternoonExpress

Medical aftermath

Two weeks ago, Alison suffered a brain aneurysm. She has been in high care at a public hospital since she has no medical aid and is unable to earn an income at present. A trust account has been established in Alison’s name to cover the current and considerable costs she is bound to face. The account has been established by well-wishers and will be managed by Alison’s legal team and other professionals who have stepped forward. (Donations can be made to Nedbank Trust Account No 1302230492. For international donations, include SWIFT code NEDSZAJJ.) [caption id="attachment_2409124" align="alignnone" width="1272"]alison botha sons Rape survivor and writer Alison Botha with her sons Daniel and Matthew on 6 June 2009. (Photo: Gallo Images / Weekend Post / Bob Hopkin)[/caption] As Alison, now in her 50s, grew older and after the birth of her two “miracle” sons, her physical health deteriorated. She has suffered with, at times, debilitating medical problems as a direct result of the injuries she sustained during her vicious attack by Du Toit and Kruger. [caption id="attachment_2409119" align="alignnone" width="1769"]alison botha interview Rape survivor and writer Alison Botha during an interview in Cape Town on 24 February 2012. (Photo: Gallo Images / Foto24 / Yunus Mohamed)[/caption] The real price for Alison of being a survivor is the “unseen” pain that remains within the aching scars, permanent reminders of the horror as well as living with the ongoing agony of her rearranged innards. To be a survivor is a burden, to always be “OK” is hard work … and when Alison needed help she did not reach out.  No one has compensated her for the fact that the two men who attacked her were out on bail on serious GBV charges and that they are now free after serving 30 years.

Parole terror

[caption id="attachment_1757036" align="alignnone" width="2000"]alison attackers parole Convicted rapists Theuns Kruger and Frans du Toit. (Photo: Supplied | Sharpened using AI)[/caption] Du Toit and Kruger were freed on parole in July 2023. Alison received a phone call to inform her about Du Toit’s impending release while she learnt of Kruger’s in the media. The survivor had actively fought every one of their attempts at freedom. Yet this time she received the call notifying her of Du Toit’s release as a fait accompli. [caption id="attachment_2406837" align="alignnone" width="758"]alison botha frans du toit One of the men serving a life sentence for the brutal attack on Alison Botha, Frans du Toit, on 23 April 2012 at Grootvlei Prison in Bloemfontein. (Photo: Gallo Images / Volksbald / Marinus Mulder)[/caption] She was not consulted despite having been registered with the Department of Correctional Services and thus could not offer objections. A formal application for review of the Minister’s decision has subsequently been launched in the Gauteng Local Division. At the time, Tania Koen, Alison’s legal representative, told News24 that Alison had felt “disillusioned and terrified” at the release of her rapist attackers. In 2016, at a reunion of all the players who stepped in to save Alison’s life that night, she told Riaan Marais of The Herald that “the attack has put me on this path where I get to travel the world and help inspire other people”. Alison has been invited to 35 countries to share her story. “I love seeing the reactions from different people when they watch the movie, the way people come to me afterwards and tell me what it meant to them.” What surprised her most was the way many men reacted to her story, with many unable to read her book or sit through the film. “I think many men take it personally, or they feel guilty about what other men did to me. But I want to tell them it is not necessary. There are more good men than bad men out there,” Botha said. DM Follow Daily Maverick for further updates on this story. To donate to the Trust Fund: Tania Koen Attorneys Nedbank Trust Account No 1302230492. For international donations, include SWIFT code NEDSZAJJ.

Alison Botha became a national symbol as one of the first rape survivors publicly to identify herself in South Africa after her attackers, Frans du Toit and Theuns Kruger, abducted and gang raped her in 1994 before repeatedly slitting her throat and disembowelling her.

In speaking out, she erased the stigma and shame which surrounded rape at the time, leading many women to suffer in silence across the globe. 

https://youtu.be/uQ2Ozd8z2UM

alison botha fight for life Rape survivor and writer Alison Botha. (Photo: Gallo Images / Sunday Times / Brett Eloff)



Alison became an international embodiment of resilience and has been the recipient globally of many accolades and awards for her strength.

Her assailants had left her for dead on Schoenmakerskop, a remote beach outside Gqeberha (then Port Elizabeth) and her miraculous will to survive led to the publication of her book, I Have Life – Alison’s Journey, which this writer was privileged to have ghostwritten in 1997.

i have a life Book cover: Facebook



It went on to be a South African bestseller with more than 95,000 copies sold and went into several reprints to reach millions across the globe. The book has been translated into multiple languages and Alison’s horror and triumph were turned into an award-winning 2016 documentary by Uga Carlini, simply titled Alison.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WIvFTrJGWCY

Chris Jansen, the judge who originally sentenced Du Toit (who received three life sentences and Kruger who received one life sentence plus 25 years) said both men should be removed from society “for the rest of their lives”.

“I was at the scene where she was assaulted. She crawled naked on a dirt road to the tarmac where she lay down, then two cars stopped by her. The first driver just looked at her like that and then drove off and the second one helped her.”

Having left a mutilated Alison for dead, they were surprised to learn during their arrest soon afterwards that she had lived. The two men were buttering bread with the knife they had used to disembowel Alison and were planning to abduct and murder another victim later that day.

They were both out on bail for similar offences.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=19tJYqpYWH8&ab_channel=AfternoonExpress

Medical aftermath


Two weeks ago, Alison suffered a brain aneurysm.

She has been in high care at a public hospital since she has no medical aid and is unable to earn an income at present.

A trust account has been established in Alison’s name to cover the current and considerable costs she is bound to face. The account has been established by well-wishers and will be managed by Alison’s legal team and other professionals who have stepped forward.

(Donations can be made to Nedbank Trust Account No 1302230492. For international donations, include SWIFT code NEDSZAJJ.)

alison botha sons Rape survivor and writer Alison Botha with her sons Daniel and Matthew on 6 June 2009. (Photo: Gallo Images / Weekend Post / Bob Hopkin)



As Alison, now in her 50s, grew older and after the birth of her two “miracle” sons, her physical health deteriorated.

She has suffered with, at times, debilitating medical problems as a direct result of the injuries she sustained during her vicious attack by Du Toit and Kruger.

alison botha interview Rape survivor and writer Alison Botha during an interview in Cape Town on 24 February 2012. (Photo: Gallo Images / Foto24 / Yunus Mohamed)



The real price for Alison of being a survivor is the “unseen” pain that remains within the aching scars, permanent reminders of the horror as well as living with the ongoing agony of her rearranged innards.

To be a survivor is a burden, to always be “OK” is hard work … and when Alison needed help she did not reach out. 

No one has compensated her for the fact that the two men who attacked her were out on bail on serious GBV charges and that they are now free after serving 30 years.

Parole terror


alison attackers parole Convicted rapists Theuns Kruger and Frans du Toit. (Photo: Supplied | Sharpened using AI)



Du Toit and Kruger were freed on parole in July 2023. Alison received a phone call to inform her about Du Toit’s impending release while she learnt of Kruger’s in the media.

The survivor had actively fought every one of their attempts at freedom. Yet this time she received the call notifying her of Du Toit’s release as a fait accompli.

alison botha frans du toit One of the men serving a life sentence for the brutal attack on Alison Botha, Frans du Toit, on 23 April 2012 at Grootvlei Prison in Bloemfontein. (Photo: Gallo Images / Volksbald / Marinus Mulder)



She was not consulted despite having been registered with the Department of Correctional Services and thus could not offer objections. A formal application for review of the Minister’s decision has subsequently been launched in the Gauteng Local Division.

At the time, Tania Koen, Alison’s legal representative, told News24 that Alison had felt “disillusioned and terrified” at the release of her rapist attackers.

In 2016, at a reunion of all the players who stepped in to save Alison’s life that night, she told Riaan Marais of The Herald that “the attack has put me on this path where I get to travel the world and help inspire other people”.

Alison has been invited to 35 countries to share her story.

“I love seeing the reactions from different people when they watch the movie, the way people come to me afterwards and tell me what it meant to them.”

What surprised her most was the way many men reacted to her story, with many unable to read her book or sit through the film.

“I think many men take it personally, or they feel guilty about what other men did to me. But I want to tell them it is not necessary. There are more good men than bad men out there,” Botha said. DM

Follow Daily Maverick for further updates on this story.

To donate to the Trust Fund:

Tania Koen Attorneys
Nedbank Trust Account No 1302230492.
For international donations, include SWIFT code NEDSZAJJ.

Comments

dalamba127 Oct 14, 2024, 10:54 PM

I am staunchly against the death penalty and I am not a lawyer. That said, the fact that these guys were out on bail, and the severity of their crime against Ms Botha, surely should rule out any possibility of parole? UK's whole-life sentence (given e.g. to Lucy Letby) not a bad idea for SA?

Rob Fisher Oct 15, 2024, 06:38 AM

I know where you are coming from. "Hanging someone by the neck until dead" is barbaric. BUT these 2 are barbaric people. So do we want to get down to their level? No. If we did then we would chop them up with a knife. The prison cost is the cost of a 5 star hotel, for 50 years.

jim Oct 15, 2024, 08:11 AM

Yes, it's crazy to think the government gives just over R2k/month as a pension to law-abiding citizens who worked and paid taxes their whole lives but spends more than R10k/month to keep a criminal in jail. Something's not right here.

Willem Boshoff Oct 15, 2024, 08:31 AM

It's unconscionable that we spend R10k a month on violent criminals while underfed children get inadequate education and no healthcare. Criminals' human rights are protected at the expense of that of good people. Insanity.

dalamba127 Oct 15, 2024, 10:30 PM

Where does that money. Judge Cameron has long criticized the SA prison system. Oom Piet must explain.

Mike Pragmatist Oct 15, 2024, 08:22 AM

This is SA , where "life" does nor mean life, and the the chances of parole are directly proportionate to who you killed.

dalamba127 Oct 15, 2024, 10:28 PM

Perhaps the issue is that Ms Botha survived? I would love to learn more about 1) our parole system and, 2) seeing as this tragedy happened during the transition, under which laws were these 2 people tried? (Would've been too young at the time). Can DM enlighten point 1?

alastairmgf Oct 15, 2024, 06:22 AM

It is high time the whole sentencing matter is reviewed. Multiple life sentences which run concurrently and people who are given parole. One of those was given Life plus 25 years. Why was he then released? In the USA sentences of 250 years are common. Those criminals are never released.

Mike Pragmatist Oct 15, 2024, 08:35 AM

Our sentencing and judicial system in respect of killings is laughable. But we cannot try compare our crime-ridden country , the voterscand government, laws and judicial system, with a first world country like the USA. We have approximately 1/6th the population - flip the stats for crime .....

John Goldreich Oct 15, 2024, 07:19 AM

Is the account in Alison’s name.

Skinyela Oct 15, 2024, 09:09 AM

Trust account

Marianne Thamm Oct 15, 2024, 11:23 AM

Nedbank Tania Koen Attorneys Trust Account No 1302230492. For international donations, include SWIFT code NEDSZAJJ.

Rod MacLeod Oct 15, 2024, 07:26 AM

I have donated. Please tell us how we can support the application to have their release reviewed. This is an outrage on Alison and society committed by a thick as pig-sh parole board.

Les Thorpe Oct 15, 2024, 08:41 AM

S.A.'s criminal (in)justice system is not fit for purpose. Once a perp murders one person, he/she is now "free" to murder five, ten, etc., others as if/when caught, he/she will effectively only receive a single life sentence due to "concurrency", and even less as a consequence of parole.

Peter Geddes Oct 15, 2024, 08:45 AM

Comments moderation clearly failed here.

Jean Racine Oct 15, 2024, 10:58 AM

I beg to differ Peter. Some readers approve this comment and others like it; readers for whom this is normal discourse and language.

hndray002 Oct 15, 2024, 12:32 PM

I most whole heartedly agree with Jean Racine

creditor Oct 15, 2024, 09:00 AM

South Africa really needs to reacess the sentencing guidelines. Life should mean the rest of your natural life. Unfortunately SA will never bring the death penalty back because that would be an ideal end to the 2 lowlifes that committed this crime.

virginia crawford Oct 19, 2024, 06:12 AM

Hard labour should be brought back.

Richard Robinson Oct 15, 2024, 09:21 AM

Those who break the rules of a civilized society should not be treated in a civilized manner.

Skinyela Oct 15, 2024, 09:22 AM

Human psyche is very complex, to the extent that there're humans who are capable of slitting someone's throat @10:30, grab something to eat @10:35 and fall asleep @10:50... And sleep like a baby. Buttering a bread with the very knife!!! Still have an appetite...

creditor Oct 15, 2024, 09:31 AM

I think we need more info on who is controlling the trust account that the donations are going into. If anyone has this info please post.

Marianne Thamm Oct 15, 2024, 11:17 AM

The account is being controlled by Tania Koen, Alison's attorney assisted by the advocate who was the prosecutor in the original case.

Rod MacLeod Oct 15, 2024, 07:18 PM

Shame on your suspicions.

David Grant Gilson Oct 15, 2024, 09:49 AM

20+ years ago my sister was shot dead by her neighbours' son (17) while his parents were out. That was 4 months after he shot dead her partner. I attended the entire trial: the level of incompetence then was already staggering but he was convicted on circumstantial evidence. He's out now too.

Rodshep Oct 15, 2024, 10:35 AM

I support the death penalty 100%. Much better then allowing low life's like this back into society. I don't understand the parole system in this country either. People accused of staggering crimes are free to go and do it again. Entire system needs to be over hauled. Life is life is life.

hndray002 Oct 15, 2024, 12:37 PM

I concur with Rod Shepherd

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Oct 15, 2024, 10:04 PM

Be careful what you wish for. The law of unintended consequence is that people who know they face the death penalty if caught will kill more people to prevent that outcome because they have nothing to lose, resulting more innocent deaths.

Skinyela Oct 15, 2024, 11:19 AM

"The first driver just looked at her like that and then drove off" Was the 1st driver ever identified? May he/she never have peace in his/her life...

Anna V Oct 15, 2024, 11:38 AM

DM, I want to donate from abroad. However my bank requires a physical address (not PO or Private Bag) of the payee or company. Do you have an address we could use?

Marianne Thamm Oct 15, 2024, 04:03 PM

Let me find out for you

Anso Thom Oct 15, 2024, 06:18 PM

Nedbank, 135 Rivonia Campus, Sandton, 2196

Just another Comment Oct 15, 2024, 11:49 AM

If murder and rape can be proven to be premeditated, I'm 100% behind the death sentence. I can't see why these evil people are allowed to walk amongst us again. But in the absence of the death sentence, it may sound like a meme, but rapists should be castrated. Fullstop!

Jubilee 1516 Oct 15, 2024, 11:59 AM

Impossible to rehabilitate du Toit and Kruger in or out of prison. There is only one way to deal with the likes of them.

D'Esprit Dan Oct 15, 2024, 08:23 PM

?

mskingon Oct 15, 2024, 01:49 PM

Reading this article makes me angry, sad and in awe. Angry at these two thugs who are now out of prison while Allison remains with the scars, sad at the lack of compassion by the prison authorities but at the same time in awe of Alisons will under odds which were severely stacked against her-

Middle aged Mike Oct 15, 2024, 03:56 PM

Everything about this story other than the staggering courage and fortitude of its heroin enrages me.

D'Esprit Dan Oct 15, 2024, 08:24 PM

100%

thuto47 Oct 15, 2024, 04:54 PM

I truly suggest that the parole given to those two worse than senseless creatures be reviewed. And their parole review process be given highest priority, so that at least, the latest the two creatures must be back behind the bars by the 31 December 2024! Praise Alison's spirit to live!

dalamba127 Oct 15, 2024, 10:40 PM

Yes.

Johan Buys Oct 15, 2024, 06:53 PM

Hopefully money helps. Hopefully also, these two meet an extremely brutal end very soon. DM can’t organize that, I know, but thanks for this effort!

D'Esprit Dan Oct 15, 2024, 08:11 PM

Absolutely disgusting that these two were ever paroled. Sick. I'll be making a donation.

Lian van den Heever Oct 16, 2024, 07:11 AM

You are a true Winner. A symbol of hope for Sa NOW. You are part of a loooooong queue of women of South Africa who came on top. Please allow me to refer to the Voortrekker Monument and Women's Memorial showing women's stories. Including yours.

Patrick O'Shea Oct 16, 2024, 07:54 AM

It may have been useful to post recent close-ups and latest addresses of the two lowlifes so we can all give them a wide berth, or would that be too unwoke? I have tried to donate but get told "incorrect bank details". Trust accounts are not listed as possible beneficiary accounts on the FNB app.

paul61 Oct 16, 2024, 09:47 AM

Attorney's trust accounts are no different to a 'cheque' or 'current' account from a depositor's perspective. No need to mention "trust" when donating money into the bank account, but do indicate it is for "Alison Botha" as the attorney needs to identify the purpose of the funds.

Patrick O'Shea Oct 16, 2024, 10:11 AM

Thank you.