Dailymaverick logo

Maverick News

This article is more than a year old

Maverick News

BEE laws are here to stay to redress the imbalances of the past, says labour minister

Taking questions in the National Assembly on Wednesday, Labour Minister Nomakhosazana Meth said that employment equity policies need to be expedited — and another 20,000 labour inspectors would soon be hired to ensure compliance.
BEE laws are here to stay to redress the imbalances of the past, says labour minister

Twenty-thousand interns will shortly be appointed as labour inspectors to ensure that businesses are complying with employment equity legislation, Labour Minister Nomakhosazana Meth told the National Assembly on Wednesday.

She was responding to a question about the number of companies which are currently non-compliant with the laws, and acknowledged: “The private sector is found wanting”.

Meth had been asked by ANC MP Sello Maeco whether her department had collected data on the state of transformation in the financial sector.

The minister said white people still dominated the sector, with representation of 58.8% as compared with black representation at 18%. This showed, she said, the need to “expedite employment equity policies”.

Later in the sitting, the minister was asked by Freedom Front Plus MP Heloïse Denner whether her department would “do away with race-based legislation”.

Meth responded: “It will be difficult to redress the imbalances of the past merely by ignoring race… Unfortunately, my department is not intending to do away with those laws.”

Julius Malema’s children take centre stage


The labour minister was appearing before the National Assembly as one of the ministers from the economic cluster tasked with answering MPs’ questions.

With Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana out of action, apparently due to ill health, his department was represented by his deputies, David Masondo (ANC) and Ashor Sarupen (DA).

Sarupen became embroiled in a verbal bunfight with the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) after failing to answer a question about scholar transport and nutrition to the Fighters’ satisfaction.

Questioned by EFF MP Veronica Mente about whether the National Treasury set standard rates for transporting and feeding schoolchildren, Sarupen responded that this did not fall within the responsibilities of the department — and was then accused by Mente of being out of touch with the realities of feeding schemes and scholar transport issues due to having his children in a private school.

Sarupen clarified that he did not have children — but added: “I am aware that [EFF leader] Honourable [Julius] Malema has his kids in a private school and I’m sure they’re privately transported as well.”

This prompted a furious outburst from Malema on the virtual platform, who accused Sarupen of “being a coward and fighting children”.

Said Malema: “I went to a public school; I come from a family which has got nothing. I’m not like him from a privileged family.”

The EFF leader also delivered a thinly veiled threat of violence, saying: “I can attend to you ideologically, theoretically, physically and otherwise, including outside… I am not responsible for your father giving birth to a brainless stupid minister.”

Sarupen backed down, saying: “If I have in any way offended any member of the EFF, I withdraw.”

State Capture-accused MK MP Lucky Montana subsequently offered to give Sarupen a lecture on the joys of fatherhood — a gesture rejected by the House chair, Werner Horn.

Concerns raised about Ithala Bank


Among the topics in focus on Wednesday afternoon was Ithala Bank: the KwaZulu-Natal financial institution founded by Mangosuthu Buthelezi which recently had its licence suspended for failing to meet the Financial Sector Conduct Authority’s financial soundness regulations.

Masondo told MPs that while Ithala had no banking licence, another bank would stand in for it, with three banks in negotiations over this.

“We are dealing with the problem together with Treasury officials,” said Masondo.

When asked by ActionSA whether either the Treasury or the KwaZulu-Natal provincial government planned to inject capital into Ithala to prevent a repeat of the VBS Mutual Bank collapse, Masondo replied: “At this stage, there is no plan to recapitalise.”

ActionSA released a statement after the National Assembly sitting expressing concern that the “worrying confirmation that [recapitalisation] is not going to happen now places the bank’s continued operation at serious risk”.

Should whites be penalised for not opening their doors to census counters?


One of the more unusual contributions to Wednesday’s Q&A came from State Capture-accused MK MP Siyabonga Gama, in reference to the ongoing controversy over the utility of the latest census results.

Gama, addressing Deputy Minister in the Presidency Kenneth Morolong, pointed out that the highest undercount in the country was in Cape Town — which he claimed was because white Capetonians were not willing to open their doors to black and coloured census enumerators.

Gama asked whether Morolong would consider, in such cases, invoking a clause of the Statistics Act making it an offence to obstruct the work of the census.

Morolong responded that it was hoped that current amendments to the Act under consideration would “give it more teeth”. DM

Comments

ttshililo2 Sep 19, 2024, 07:38 AM

The gall and the cheek by the FF+ MP to even ask that question, is simply breathtaking even if it is not surprising.

Harold Porter Sep 19, 2024, 09:11 AM

Why is it a cheeky question? If after 30 years of BEE there is still a disparity, is it not valid to question whether BEE is actually the solution to the problem?

Ndabenhle Ngubane Sep 19, 2024, 10:48 AM

BEE was a good policy. It was however hijacked by politically connected people, hence slow progress on the redress. I wish all shared GIVEN to Ramaphosa, Sexwale, etc were given to employees instead. That would have been true empowerment.

Karl Sittlinger Sep 19, 2024, 11:24 AM

"slow progress on the redress" I am sorry but it has and is being used as an excuse to participate in industrial scale looting of the fiscus. Instead of empowering it has entrenched rent seeking not actually helping this country. That is the reality and that is how we must judge BEE.

Harold Porter Sep 19, 2024, 12:55 PM

I don't dispute the original justification of BEE. However, after 30 years it is clear that it has served to fill with incompetence and corruption the very government departments that should be uplifting the poor, who are now trapped in poverty by those very same government institutions.

laurantsystems Sep 19, 2024, 11:13 AM

Much like the the gall and the cheek of those who dared to struggle against apartheid, eh? As the IRR points out, there are more racist laws in SA now, than there were under apartheid. SA is still suffering under apartheid. Better get used to people struggling against the regime's neo-apartheid....

laurantsystems Sep 19, 2024, 11:14 AM

So the Special Olympics for the already connected, those who drive Ferraris and wear ugly, pointy shoes already, will just continue. Big surprise.

Malcolm McManus Sep 19, 2024, 11:54 AM

Any idea how long it will take until that can be considered a fair question? I am hoping not centuries like in America where certain races, except one still need a hand up. It must be degrading to be dosed with advantage, to help align oneself.

Pieter van de Venter Sep 19, 2024, 12:24 PM

Why is it a cheek?. BEE is baded on race. Decisionmakers are ALL black these days - why scared of competition from 8%?

ttshililo2 Sep 19, 2024, 07:38 AM

The gall and the cheek by the FF+ MP to even ask that question, is simply breathtaking even if it is not surprising.

jamesmichael975 Sep 19, 2024, 08:14 AM

The ANC is a racist party. Her confidence is mis placed and forgets they are part of a unity government. BEE is anti poor and will end soon

ttshililo2 Sep 19, 2024, 09:43 AM

I say this with much deference: Mike, you wouldn’t survive a day of actual racism in this country if you think BBBEEE and the like are racist. This wilful ignorance to misunderstand the need for these are just fatuous to say the least.

laurantsystems Sep 19, 2024, 11:34 AM

Your denialism is an insult to the white people who get denied jobs because of racist BEE, or whose businesses struggle because of racist BEE. Please don't be that guy who, like an apartheid denier, plays word games to deny the impact of the ANC's neo-apartheid racism on its white victims.

ttshililo2 Sep 19, 2024, 01:12 PM

Please stop fibbing once again, BBBEE does not discount meritocracy and it does not exclude 7% of the population. Do you ever comment on the countless white women who have benefited from BBBEE. Just stop lying for goodness sakes.

Matt 218 Sep 19, 2024, 12:06 PM

How has racism affected you directly? Please don't generalize

Malcolm McManus Sep 19, 2024, 12:23 PM

Some people need a hand up. BBBEE is more of trying to pull a certain race group down instead of others up. We need an alternative to BBBEE that stimulates the economy, creates employment for a far larger group of people. Dangle a carrot instead of brandishing a whip. Try it. It might just work.

regalh Sep 19, 2024, 03:19 PM

I was denied a job because I'm too white. To me that is racist. Race based employment practice.

Cobuswelgemoed Sep 19, 2024, 08:25 AM

I volunteered to assist with the census in the Northern Suburbs of Cape Town. Suffice it to say the organisation was a disaster. Personally I, and most of my neighbours completed the census online. I never saw an enumerator in our area and no one I know did. What a cheek Morolong has.

Nos Feratu Sep 19, 2024, 08:59 AM

They have had 30 years to address imbalances of the past. BEE has had ample time. Do away with it asap

Harold Porter Sep 19, 2024, 09:08 AM

To quote another DM article "The fight against [race-based] workplace discrimination is a moral imperative essential to the country’s progress"...lol

laurantsystems Sep 19, 2024, 11:15 AM

It is indeed absolutely hilarious how the ANC regime can just rename its version of apartheid, and think anybody would be fooled by its racism.

Matt 218 Sep 19, 2024, 12:13 PM

It's not about freedom or redress at all. The "opressed", like slaves never look to be freed or empowered. They want to be the oppressor or the slaver. Nothing to do with freedom

Malcolm McManus Sep 19, 2024, 01:37 PM

Ultimate retribution, but only problem is nobody wants to be a slave. You can't be a slaver without slaves, so the cycle repeats itself in a different format and you just end up with a different select minority group of slavers or more commonly known as cadres

alastairmgf Sep 19, 2024, 09:31 AM

It is time BBBEE and AA policies are consigned to the dust heap of failed ideologies. Having worked in big corporate for many years they are a disaster. A lowering of standards all round.

Caroline de Braganza Sep 19, 2024, 09:45 AM

The private sector is found wanting because of the failure of Basic Education - they cannot employ people whose literacy and numeracy skills do not meet the requirements of the job. Fix Basic Education first. As the late Pravin would say, connect the dots.

Lynda Tyrer Sep 19, 2024, 10:13 AM

BEEE needs to be cancelled if this govt want jobs created then they need to stop their nonsense of demanding and dictating until they do that they can sit with an unemployment figure of 50%plus. 30 years have passed and there has been absolutely no successes the anc can be proud of.

William Kelly Sep 19, 2024, 11:10 AM

If you cannot measure a thing you cannot manage it. Where are the measures for BEE? Where are the measures for labour compliance? Where does the number of 20,000 inspectors come from? Thin air I suspect.

Malcolm McManus Sep 19, 2024, 02:39 PM

Good observation. The 20 000 inspectors is unnecessary BEE job creation out of thin air at tax payers expense. Yet another drain on an already drained society.

Ken Randell Sep 19, 2024, 11:51 AM

Letting loose a group of interns as labour inspectors who have minimal training, understanding or work experience is not going to turn out well. Presumably that group will comprise only EE appointments, all of whom are likely to have been born post 1994. 30 years on and social engineering remains.

Ken Randell Sep 19, 2024, 11:58 AM

Does Siyabonga Gama know if Cape Town had the highest "undercount" in the census? The numbers don't support that assertion. For him to ascribe a racial bias to his thoughts is irresponsible as an MP - divisive and pathetic.

Malcolm McManus Sep 19, 2024, 01:27 PM

In this country you would be a bloody fool to open up your doors to any stranger. I entertain census enumerators, who have always been very pleasant and efficient in my experiences, over the fence. I imagine black or coloured census enumerators would get worse reception in the Cape Flats.

Malcolm McManus Sep 19, 2024, 01:27 PM

In this country you would be a bloody fool to open up your doors to any stranger. I entertain census enumerators, who have always been very pleasant and efficient in my experiences, over the fence. I imagine black or coloured census enumerators would get worse reception in the Cape Flats.

Matt 218 Sep 19, 2024, 12:03 PM

Would love to see someone actually accepts Julius' invitation to a fight. The boy is all talk and unable to back it up. Barking dogs don't bite

regalh Sep 19, 2024, 03:11 PM

The first apartheid law was the Prohibition of Mixed Marriages Act, 8/7/1949 - 42 years ago Apartheid legislation was repealed on 17 June 1991 - 33 years ago If you cant fix it in 33 years, how long do you think you will need Minister Meth?

Joe Soap Sep 19, 2024, 04:43 PM

BEE legislation is racist and coercive, constraining private companies to conclude more costly tender contracts, the private companies being advantaged by race.

Slightly Irritated Sep 19, 2024, 05:28 PM

Oh please BEE is used as an excuse for connected cadres to loot the taxpayers, nothing else!

Rod MacLeod Sep 19, 2024, 07:00 PM

You're living in a kleptocracy run by severely inept under-achievers - suck it up or move out.

Jane Crankshaw Sep 19, 2024, 09:52 PM

Madam - two wrongs don't make a right!