Dailymaverick logo

Maverick News

This article is more than a year old

Maverick News

Minister narrowly escapes being in Cyril’s firing line over contentious bill

President Cyril Ramaphosa says the Education Minister Siviwe Gwarube’s decision to boycott the ceremony where the much-contested Basic Education Laws Amendment Bill was officially signed into law is not grounds for dismissal.
Minister narrowly escapes being in Cyril’s firing line over contentious bill

Minister of Basic Education Siviwe Gwarube’s readiness to implement the Basic Education Laws Amendment Bill keeps her out of the red, according to President Ramaphosa. 

Speaking during an engagement with media at the Union Buildings on Friday, 13 September, Ramaphosa admitted that the contention regarding the bill has been a sore point for the DA, the party which Gwarube belongs to. 

But this week Gwarube told a department workshop that she will implement the bill if it is signed into law.

“I am not concerned about this. I think we need to know that the issue of the Bela Bill has been a challenge even from the party that she comes from. I think if one puts that into context, one will understand that one has to look for the positive and say, the minister has been unequivocal in clearly saying, once the president has signed the bill, I am going to implement it. That to me is the bottom line,” the president reiterated.   

“If the minister ever says she will not implement it, she will be fired — plain and simple. Non-attendance is a matter of concern.”  

Gwarube took the hard line by not attending the ceremony earlier in the day, saying that it should be sent back to Parliament to be amended as it does not represent millions of learners across the country in its current form. 

She then explained the importance of reaching a compromise, especially in the context of the Government of National Unity (GNU).

Legal action expected


The DA will also be forging ahead with legal action against the implementation of the bill. In a statement issued by the party, following the signing ceremony, the DA explained that there is no agreement between the GNU partners, which they firmly reject.

Ramaphosa signed the Bela Bill into law on Friday, but announced that he would be suspending the implementation of two specific clauses in the bill for a three-month consultation period. 

Read more: Ramaphosa and the Bela Bill — the power of political surprise, but at what cost?

The bill seeks, among other things, to make Grade R the new compulsory school starting age; to provide penalties for parents and guardians who do not ensure that their children are in school; and to confirm that corporal punishment is no longer allowed in schools, with penalties for those found guilty of such offences, Daily Maverick reported.

Daily Maverick’s Victoria O’Regan writes that Clause 4 of the bill provides for a provincial head of education to override a school’s language policy – that authority currently lies with school governing bodies. Clause 5 provides for the provincial education department heads to control admission policies. 

GNU collapse would be ‘ghastly’


Ramaphosa reiterated the importance of the GNU succeeding, and further said that the collective had no choice but to forge ahead.

“It will be quite ghastly for South Africa because the establishment of the GNU is what has lifted the confidence and the spirits of many in our country. Many of those one speaks to say that they feel that there is a direction to move forward.

“Prior to the elections, people were concerned, investors were holding back and our economic growth trajectory seems to have been on a stall. But now the GNU has been able to open many opportunities,” said the president. 

The GNU will be forming a dispute resolution committee, as stipulated in the formation’s statement of intent. The committee will consist of all 10 parties who are signatories to the agreement, and will seek to create a platform to discuss key issues over time. DM

Comments

Andrew Blaine Sep 14, 2024, 06:52 AM

Putting the responsibility for choosing the language of education and admission policy in schools in the hands of a politician, thereby overriding the wishes of a community. Is bound to lead to dissension and denial of the basic rights of that community!

Bongane Maphanga Sep 14, 2024, 10:41 AM

HOD's are technocratic appointments, not Political

titus khoza Sep 14, 2024, 05:48 PM

"Overriding the wishes of a community", you say. Please kindly explain which "a community" are talking about.

Andrew Lowry Sep 15, 2024, 12:22 PM

Perhaps you could define yours .... was a perfectly innocuous response to an obviously biased question looking to stimulate a language/demographic debate. No change and I will refrain from any future comments. Goodbye

Denise Smit Sep 14, 2024, 07:07 AM

There is only a government of national disunity. By opting to destroy Afrikaans and Afrikaans schools and universities the ANC and Cyril are making a mockery of unity. This is what happens if the provincial department can unilaterally control admission of learners and language medium at schools

Matthews.mc98 Sep 15, 2024, 02:13 PM

But provincial education departments are the legal custodians of schools!! How governance accountability in schools affect universities in general, needs to be explained!!

elvissmith820 Sep 14, 2024, 07:31 AM

Where Panyaza Lesufi is involved nothing good comes out of it what I find funny tsotsi taal is mixed with Afrikaans and it's a language spoken by millions in the Townships and in Kwandebele I mean everyone has the right to speak his own language and learn his language at school.

William Dryden Sep 16, 2024, 10:50 AM

People learn their language from their parents, not at school, what they learn at school is how to read and write their language.

geoffry.heald Sep 14, 2024, 07:46 AM

The Basic Education Amendment Bill is education for mass unemployment. The ANC’s greatest fear is that the creativity and ingenuity of South Africans will be released. If it were they would not last a millisecond

Matthews.mc98 Sep 15, 2024, 02:16 PM

The BELA Act (please get used to that), has nothing to do with employment imperatives!! If you’ve seen such a stipulation, please refer us to the relevant section of the BELA Act!!

Johan Buys Sep 14, 2024, 09:18 AM

Many people confuse race and language - at times deliberately for political reasons. There are probably more black and colored race Afrikaans home-language families in SA than white English ones! Certainly far more than black Venda, Ndebele, etc families.

Noelsoyizwap Sep 14, 2024, 10:32 AM

CSE not in the Bill and no provisions or relevance to it. Should the state wishto include CSE, would have to engage with stakeholders. SGB will retain control over language and admissions policies, with the approval from the HoD in accordance with the Constitution, ensuring non-arbitrary process.

Indeed Jhb Sep 14, 2024, 10:39 AM

Three months for discussion? Really - so he knows it should have gone back to Parliament

Indeed Jhb Sep 14, 2024, 10:55 AM

Well done Minister for not attending this 'event'

Steve Davidson Sep 15, 2024, 08:37 AM

So right. In fact, maybe a statement that 'I hope you realise I didn't write this cr*p but I'm stuck with it' might help as well. Hopefully the clever DA have already got a handbook on how to deal with the machinations of an ANC led GNU.

Noelsoyizwap Sep 14, 2024, 11:37 AM

Inclusiveness of the bill over exclucivity desires of some communities is the bone of contention here. The Bill requires school governing bodies to submit their language policies for approval and that these policies must consider the language needs of the broader community.

Indeed Jhb Sep 14, 2024, 05:24 PM

Does the 'community' include the families of student bused in from outside the feeding area of a school? Just how big is the broader community?

Noelsoyizwap Sep 14, 2024, 06:21 PM

"Well done Minister for not attending this ‘event’ I cannot dignify lawlessness.

Peter Oosthuizen Sep 16, 2024, 08:37 AM

What makes being absent unlawful? Should we follow Putin's totalitarian example?

Noelsoyizwap Sep 15, 2024, 09:11 AM

Yes, but instead of wanting to enforce apartheid covertly, use the law creatively as section 4&5 provides. Schools are government property and their efficient use must be encouraged. Shouldn't have half empty afrikaans schools.

Matthews.mc98 Sep 15, 2024, 02:27 PM

The learners you are saying are bussed from other communities, have a right to attend any public school of their parents’ choice. The scholar transport policies stipulates the approved distance between the child’s home & the chosen school!! Please avoid misleading the DM readers

Matthews.mc98 Sep 15, 2024, 02:27 PM

The learners you are saying are bussed from other communities, have a right to attend any public school of their parents’ choice. The scholar transport policies stipulates the approved distance between the child’s home & the chosen school!! Please avoid misleading the DM readers

Noelsoyizwap Sep 14, 2024, 11:45 AM

SA cannot be outsmarted by FF+ and Co. AfriForum has steadfastly been objecting to the clauses which amends the right of SGBs to have the final say about schools’ admission and language policies. Some have sought to make it seen as the "abortion bill" just to discredit it.

Noelsoyizwap Sep 14, 2024, 12:29 PM

DA

Indeed Jhb Sep 14, 2024, 02:11 PM

There are 500+ empty schools in Gauteng, why not use those? Much easier to break somthing that works - the fact that SGB's are now at the merci of political cadres makes the whole system a mockery. I trust that gov will now also fully fund schools and not expect SGB's to pay for needed teachers

Matthews.mc98 Sep 15, 2024, 02:31 PM

Where are these empty schools; & why don’t you state that there are lots of former model-C schools that are running at a fraction of their full capacities!! Are you aware that the public purse & parents (in some schools) pay for the children’s parents who are unable to pay for their kids

Peter Oosthuizen Sep 16, 2024, 08:39 AM

The public purse pays for most of the children in school today. If BELA required a 50% pass for matric it could have some merit!

Noelsoyizwap Sep 14, 2024, 05:37 PM

According to a DA report of 2023, the GDE has closed 11 schools in Gauteng in the past five years. This has occurred while learners continue to be taught in overcrowded classrooms, in environments not conducive to teaching or learning, while some learners have to travel out of their communities.

Indeed Jhb Sep 14, 2024, 11:49 PM

Why are the classrooms overcrowded? Because people want their children educated in schools with good pass rates. Not schools with 'teachers' who paid for or were awarded posts for being connected. And will down teaching at every possible 'strike' opportunity

Noelsoyizwap Sep 15, 2024, 08:53 AM

Well done Minister for not attending this ‘event’

Noelsoyizwap Sep 14, 2024, 06:45 PM

Prepare for the change you want. Just like everything else, entities and juristic persons included, schools are influenced by the environments they operate in. They all have a responsibility to study and adequately prepare for these changes. Resistance to environmental changes is a futile effort.

Steve Davidson Sep 15, 2024, 09:20 AM

Actually, you know what the biggest 'futile effort' is? Trying to find a word of sense in whatever you write. And you seem to write one hell of a lot of it.

Ed Rybicki Sep 15, 2024, 12:02 PM

Ad hominem attacks are a sign that you either don’t understand what is going on, or you can’t thing of a counter-argument. Either way, peurile.

Mjt Umoya Sep 15, 2024, 09:58 AM

But if the minister of justice has kickbacks from a corrupt mutual bank thats okay…it feels like the timing of all this is a little too suspect

Maj.kno Sep 15, 2024, 10:01 AM

The first cabinet reshuffle will see replacement caders installed to quell any opposition to the politburo decisions.

once.off.address Sep 15, 2024, 01:15 PM

" is not grounds for dismissal" More hue and cry about this from Squirrel and nothing about an actual criminal in the form of Simelane or her refusal to give NPA access to Zondo database. We are led by a m0 ron. Sorry.

Matthews.mc98 Sep 15, 2024, 02:11 PM

@AndrewBlaine - please note that provincial heads of departments are not politicians; but public servants in terms of Public Service Act, who are accounting officers in terms of the public Finance Management Act!! Your assumption in your comment, if false & misleading!!

Rod MacLeod Sep 16, 2024, 08:40 AM

So, these heads of department are not actually card-carrying deployed ANC cadres? They are a-political highly qualified professionals, are they? Pffffffftttt .....