Dailymaverick logo

Scorpio

This article is more than a year old

Scorpio

Reserve Bank orders Steinhoff to forfeit more than R6-billion to the State

This week, the Reserve Bank notified the Steinhoff group of companies that its funds in seven local accounts have been forfeited to the state. The forfeiture amounts to about R6-billion, plus interest — a record forfeiture for the central bank.
Reserve Bank orders Steinhoff to forfeit more than R6-billion to the State

Reserve Bank deputy governor Fundi Tshazibana published three notices and orders of forfeiture in the Government Gazette on Friday, 19 July, informing the Steinhoff group of companies that “I hereby declare and order forfeit to the state” about R6-billion in seven local accounts. 

The Steinhoff funds must be paid over to the National Revenue Fund (NRF). The NRF is in effect the government purse, which collects all revenue (by the tax man), fines and donations.  

The notices and orders were served against SAHPL (Pty) Limited, known as Steinhoff Africa Holdings, SIHPL (Pty) Limited, known as Steinhoff International Holdings, and Ibex Investment Holdings Limited, which previously was Steinhoff Investment Holdings. 

Ibex is now the new Steinhoff. 

This is a major win for the central bank on at least two fronts. Not only are they broad-chested about the sum forfeited, but it seems the forfeiture notices may have scuppered an existing court case against the Reserve Bank. 

Late last year, Ibex/Steinhof initiated proceedings in the high court in Pretoria contesting the reserve bank’s freezing order of May 2023 which froze R5.5-billion in five local accounts. 

Scorpio wrote about how Steinhoff questionably did not declare this action in its annual financial statements 

Read more on Daily Maverick: SARB freezes billions in Steinhoff accounts — but you wouldn’t notice in company financial statements

This case is now generally viewed as mostly moot. Ibex/Steinhoff is expected to put up a huge fight to set aside Tshazibana’s decision but will probably be forced to file a new application.  

The Reserve Bank’s freezing order of May 2023 and this week’s forfeiture notices and orders come after a years-long investigation, codenamed Project Castle, confirmed the central bank’s suspicion that Steinhoff and its management led by Jooste probably breached a long list of exchange control regulations. 

Scorpio understands that about R600-billion was possibly moved offshore – possibly unlawfully in many instances.

The Ibex/Steinhoff accounts held the following funds and is now forfeited to the state:


* SAHPL:

Euro account at Standard Bank: Euro40,34-million;

FNB account: R311,3-million

FNB account: R223,2-million


* SIHPL: 

FNB account: R190,9-million

FNB account: R2,23-billion

FNB account: R2,25-billion


* Ibex Investment:

FNB account: R166,6-million


DM

Comments

pronexus Jul 19, 2024, 07:55 PM

"about R600-billion was possibly moved offshore " Seriously?!?! So they collected only 1% of the loot . How does anyone move that amount out of an economy unnoticed? thats 9% of the entire country's GDP in one company?! cant be right

Johan Buys Jul 20, 2024, 11:27 AM

Ja Phil : that R600b also puzzled me. It is multiples of revenue, peak market cap, profits, etc. End of the day, people talk about by how much that circus’s market value crashed. It was never worth the R50b by which its value increased and therefore could also not lose the R50b

Jane Crankshaw Jul 19, 2024, 10:31 PM

And what do previous investors get? Nada…sweet fanny Adams …..zilch! Sounds about right for the way things go in good old SA! I wish the Reserve bank was as efficient as this in getting back something from the Guptas but…Nada ….sweet fanny Adams…zilch!

Steve Broekmann Jul 20, 2024, 07:11 AM

Agree your sentiments, of course. But is the Adams with a cute behind any relation to Fanny?

Alan Watkins Jul 20, 2024, 09:24 AM

Why? Compare two cases,state capture and Steinhoff. Guptas stole billions from the state and taxpayers. Any forfeiture of assets would compensate the state and ultimately taxpayers. Steinhoff's case is one of fraud where Steinhoff shareholders were defrauded. Why is state grabbing those assets?

nyrojama Jul 20, 2024, 10:24 AM

The State owns the PIC

Alan Watkins Jul 22, 2024, 11:04 AM

which is unjust enrichment of some shareholders at the expense of others

Thomas Cleghorn Jul 20, 2024, 09:41 AM

So does that mean that the PIC will get a refund for their bad investments?

William Dryden Jul 20, 2024, 10:15 AM

If Steinhoff unlawfully shifted R600billion off shore, then surely the banks could be complicit if the money moving off shore was not advised to the reserve bank, or am I wrong?

Rod MacLeod Jul 20, 2024, 10:35 AM

Neither SARS nor the SARB will take any precipitate action against the Guptas and their financial empire for one reason only - any chase down that rabbit hole, whichever tunnel they follow in that rabbit warren, will lead them to the nest eggs sitting in the Star Trust and Nkobi Holdings.

Colin Braude Jul 20, 2024, 01:17 PM

Quite. And while the Guptas are getting bail in an Indian court, the ANC-in-government is focusing on laying false charges at ICJ in a matter that does not concern SA.

mannian22 Jul 20, 2024, 11:45 AM

Well the anc can have a good party with lots to drink with all that money.

Lucifer's Consiglieri Jul 20, 2024, 03:36 PM

That R600-billion sounds like some pretty wild speculation. Can do better Scorpio.

Lucifer's Consiglieri Jul 20, 2024, 03:36 PM

That R600-billion sounds like some pretty wild speculation. Can do better Scorpio.

dewaomuhle Jul 20, 2024, 07:21 PM

How does someone move all that money without being detected ,was the bank complicity?

Yvette Von Faber Jul 21, 2024, 11:52 AM

What I want to know will these funds be paid back to all of the victims that lost all of their money ??

lesley.young1945 Jul 21, 2024, 12:54 PM

Has the Reserve Bank actually received these funds or is it just a wish list?

stuart.woodhead Jul 21, 2024, 01:05 PM

How do people get to R600billion when it is stated that the amount is R6billion. A massive difference but nevertheless a huge amount!

Nick Griffon Jul 22, 2024, 04:40 PM

How do you move R600 billion offshore through the banking system without red flags being raised? The banks are also guilty here.