Dailymaverick logo

Maverick News

This article is more than a year old

Maverick News

It’s now time for South Africa to take Zuma's MK party seriously

At time of writing it is simply too early for concrete election predictions, but one outcome emerging pretty clearly is that Jacob Zuma’s MK party is a political player that cannot be ignored.
It’s now time for South Africa to take Zuma's MK party seriously From virtually the moment of its inception in December 2023, the uMkhonto Wesizwe party launched by former president Jacob Zuma has been embroiled in chaos. There have been legal disputes centering on copyright issues around the party name. There have been legal disputes relating to the eligibility of Zuma to be elected to the National Assembly. There have been legal disputes relating to the battle for supremacy between Zuma and the man at one stage declared to be party leader, Jabulani Khumalo, who has now been ousted. As things stand, the day after voting, it is still totally unclear who actually leads this party, who they would send to Parliament, or who they might put forward as provincial premier candidates. The role of a figure like Duduzile Zuma — Jacob Zuma’s daughter, whose video footage suggests requires an isiZulu translator to address party events — is also ambiguous. And her apparent lack of ease in the language is relevant, because the MK party has been branded by some as “ANC yamaZulu”, or “ANC of the Zulu people”: namely, a fundamentally Zulu-interest breakaway. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=99E_Ox8TZ5w Read more in Daily Maverick: Zuma’s MK party trades on identity politics, invoking Zulu nationalism, traditional leadership The levels of disarray around this political outfit, together with its distressingly anti-constitutional outlook, have led many of us to want to disregard it altogether. But with the first results from voting districts starting to trickle in steadily, it is now clear that fairly significant numbers of voters around the country feel differently. It is also evident that although the MK party’s best results will come from KwaZulu-Natal, as was expected, the party does indeed also have pockets of support in other parts of the country, so it cannot be dismissed as an entirely localised phenomenon.
[election-engine visualisation="table" selected_year="2024" selected_election="National Assembly" selected_region="KwaZulu-Natal" show_title="1" show_blurb="1" show_buttons="0"]
With MK votes having comfortably reached six digits by 1 pm on Thursday, it might be time to remind ourselves of what its manifesto promised voters. The MK party wants to “re-centre” South Africa on “African cultural and moral values”, without specifying further what exactly that might look like. Its manifesto promises to do away with what it calls “constitutional supremacy” towards “unfettered parliamentary supremacy”. The party has at several points in the recent past shown open disdain for the judicial system and the Constitutional Court in particular, railing against the influence of “11 unelected individuals” on the lives of 60-million-plus South Africans. The manifesto further proposes that post-apartheid reconstruction “cannot be facilitated by a liberal Constitution that constrains the political power of the majority”. The party would champion a referendum to scrap the Constitution. It wants to expropriate “all” land without compensation and transfer ownership to “the people under State and traditional leadership custodianship”. That last part has raised alarm bells, even among some people who enthusiastically support radical redress, because the example of the Ingonyama Trust in KZN shows how this can become a repressive feudal system. [caption id="attachment_2206301" align="alignnone" width="720"]Jacob Zuma, MK party Former South African President Jacob Zuma gestures after voting during the South African elections, in Nkandla, South Africa. 29 May 2024. (Photo: Reuters/Rogan Ward)[/caption] It would nationalise “strategic” mines, and make a year of military service compulsory for “every young person reaching the age of 18” in order to “cultivate discipline and patriotism among our youth”. It also favours nationalising the South African Reserve Bank, all large banks and all large insurance companies. With regards to the environment, the party refers to the move away from coal as the “Un-Just Transition”. It wants to “renew” Eskom’s coal fleet and – surprise surprise – accelerate South Africa’s nuclear programme. On the the LGBTQIA+ community, Zuma also holds strong unconstitutional views. It was reported that during an MK rally in January this year Zuma showed solidarity with tribal leaders over their alleged concern about same-sex marriages. He also implied that legislation supporting same-sex marriage lacks support from the majority of South Africa. Zuma's January comments aligned which his 2006 sentiments that same-sex marriage is a “disgrace to the nation and to God”. GroundUp published an opinion piece by Zackie Achmat on the matter. Why is Jacob Zuma attacking queer people? The full MK manifesto can be read here. It’s important to note that there is no indication yet that the MK party will win sufficient votes to take sole control of any major territories, and nobody sensible is predicting that they will come anywhere close to doing so. But their results are likely to establish the party as a non-trivial arrival in the South African body politic — and they also remind us that the figure of Jacob Zuma is by no means an entirely spent political force. DM

From virtually the moment of its inception in December 2023, the uMkhonto Wesizwe party launched by former president Jacob Zuma has been embroiled in chaos.

There have been legal disputes centering on copyright issues around the party name. There have been legal disputes relating to the eligibility of Zuma to be elected to the National Assembly. There have been legal disputes relating to the battle for supremacy between Zuma and the man at one stage declared to be party leader, Jabulani Khumalo, who has now been ousted.

As things stand, the day after voting, it is still totally unclear who actually leads this party, who they would send to Parliament, or who they might put forward as provincial premier candidates.

The role of a figure like Duduzile Zuma — Jacob Zuma’s daughter, whose video footage suggests requires an isiZulu translator to address party events — is also ambiguous. And her apparent lack of ease in the language is relevant, because the MK party has been branded by some as “ANC yamaZulu”, or “ANC of the Zulu people”: namely, a fundamentally Zulu-interest breakaway.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=99E_Ox8TZ5w

Read more in Daily Maverick: Zuma’s MK party trades on identity politics, invoking Zulu nationalism, traditional leadership

The levels of disarray around this political outfit, together with its distressingly anti-constitutional outlook, have led many of us to want to disregard it altogether.

But with the first results from voting districts starting to trickle in steadily, it is now clear that fairly significant numbers of voters around the country feel differently. It is also evident that although the MK party’s best results will come from KwaZulu-Natal, as was expected, the party does indeed also have pockets of support in other parts of the country, so it cannot be dismissed as an entirely localised phenomenon.

[election-engine visualisation="table" selected_year="2024" selected_election="National Assembly" selected_region="KwaZulu-Natal" show_title="1" show_blurb="1" show_buttons="0"]

With MK votes having comfortably reached six digits by 1 pm on Thursday, it might be time to remind ourselves of what its manifesto promised voters.

The MK party wants to “re-centre” South Africa on “African cultural and moral values”, without specifying further what exactly that might look like.

Its manifesto promises to do away with what it calls “constitutional supremacy” towards “unfettered parliamentary supremacy”. The party has at several points in the recent past shown open disdain for the judicial system and the Constitutional Court in particular, railing against the influence of “11 unelected individuals” on the lives of 60-million-plus South Africans.

The manifesto further proposes that post-apartheid reconstruction “cannot be facilitated by a liberal Constitution that constrains the political power of the majority”. The party would champion a referendum to scrap the Constitution.

It wants to expropriate “all” land without compensation and transfer ownership to “the people under State and traditional leadership custodianship”. That last part has raised alarm bells, even among some people who enthusiastically support radical redress, because the example of the Ingonyama Trust in KZN shows how this can become a repressive feudal system.

Jacob Zuma, MK party Former South African President Jacob Zuma gestures after voting during the South African elections, in Nkandla, South Africa. 29 May 2024. (Photo: Reuters/Rogan Ward)



It would nationalise “strategic” mines, and make a year of military service compulsory for “every young person reaching the age of 18” in order to “cultivate discipline and patriotism among our youth”.

It also favours nationalising the South African Reserve Bank, all large banks and all large insurance companies.

With regards to the environment, the party refers to the move away from coal as the “Un-Just Transition”. It wants to “renew” Eskom’s coal fleet and – surprise surprise – accelerate South Africa’s nuclear programme.

On the the LGBTQIA+ community, Zuma also holds strong unconstitutional views. It was reported that during an MK rally in January this year Zuma showed solidarity with tribal leaders over their alleged concern about same-sex marriages. He also implied that legislation supporting same-sex marriage lacks support from the majority of South Africa. Zuma's January comments aligned which his 2006 sentiments that same-sex marriage is a “disgrace to the nation and to God”.

GroundUp published an opinion piece by Zackie Achmat on the matter. Why is Jacob Zuma attacking queer people?

The full MK manifesto can be read here.

It’s important to note that there is no indication yet that the MK party will win sufficient votes to take sole control of any major territories, and nobody sensible is predicting that they will come anywhere close to doing so.

But their results are likely to establish the party as a non-trivial arrival in the South African body politic — and they also remind us that the figure of Jacob Zuma is by no means an entirely spent political force. DM

Comments

R S May 30, 2024, 02:03 PM

MK is not a serious threat long-term. Like COPE, when Zuma finally expires so will MK. His children simply don't have the same legacy he does and the party will slowly disappear into dust. But for this election, they've undoubtedly had an impact.

hlavatican May 30, 2024, 05:44 PM

Agreed but a lesson learnt is elections are not about service delivery, honest, polices, ideology. It's about trusting your own. DA must forget about being liberal after all no one in Soweto knows what that means.

Rory Fraser May 30, 2024, 02:04 PM

Anyone who didn't see the MK as a serious threat to South Africa, is sadly in a bubble or naive

J vN May 30, 2024, 07:56 PM

Firstly, judging by the early apparent success of the MK and PA parties, it pays to have a criminal as the face of your party. SA voters apparently love voting for felons. The quality of SA's voting fodder and the leaders they vote for, is generally abysmal, with the exception of about 25% of the elctorate. Secondly, the same voting patterns of the past 30 years are being repeated, even with MK's rise. About 2/3rds of SA's voters vote for leftist, Marxist parties and have done so for 30 years. The free-market parties are only supported by about 1/3rd of the voters. The only contest that matters is the churn within the 2/3 pool of voters, who vote for parties, led by criminals, who promise them free stuff.

Kenneth FAKUDE May 30, 2024, 09:14 PM

It's all about the message, Zuma did not have a glossy manifesto, he mentioned the Roman dutch law at a time when it is thrashed by Israel in front of the whole world, he touched about the respect of Africans taken by the balance of financial power just to name a few things that he delivered in person, no campaign strategy except raw reality.

phgibb May 30, 2024, 02:13 PM

So, if things trend as they currently are, in order to remain controlling the reins of power (which they will surely want to do), the ANC will have to enter into a national coalition with at least one of the EFF or MK. Best we hold on tight as it seems like the light at the end of the election tunnel is a train (well, not a Transnet train, obviously).

Christopher Bedford May 30, 2024, 02:20 PM

Sad commentary on the population's moral compass that a corrupt buffoon has so much support - oh, wait, am I talking about Donald Trump? Can SA hide behind the excuse of being a "3rd World" nation? But after all is said and done, thirty years into a constitution that is in some ways a shining, world-leading, example of liberal democracy we still lean so far towards tribalism and feudalism in other ways, like support for idiots like JZ and *staggering* salaries for "traditional leaders" who contribute *less than nothing of value* to the GDP or any other measure of national worth.

Jacques Boshoff May 30, 2024, 03:47 PM

Incredible how successful the ANC strategy of keeping the masses stupid worked.

jodyt1981 May 31, 2024, 04:06 PM

Alot of people voting for MK purely because Zuma is a Zulu leader. Alot of people don't realize how strong cultural and traditional beliefs are still in SA.

Jon Quirk May 30, 2024, 03:08 PM

A nightmare scenario is becoming ever clearer; the failure of the NPA to bring any meaningful charges against the vast number of corrupt persons, the failure to charge the July 2021 insurrectionists, and before that, Thabo Mbeki's failure to just sack him, rather than ensure that the Arm's Deal charges were followed through and Zuma arrested - all of course because of the fears of many in the ANC, that each of these steps would have resulted in many more senior ANC, being also arrested and charged, now seems likely to result in a political nightmare, and all fundamentally as a result of a dithering, fearful President, without the cojones to do the right thing - seeking to "save" the ANC, rather than do both the right thing, and what is best for our country. Kicking the can, continually down the road, since 2007, now means it is no longer a can, but rather a nuclear bomb, that may well destroy our whole country.

virginia crawford May 31, 2024, 12:18 PM

Sad but true.

virginia crawford May 31, 2024, 12:18 PM

Sad but true.

Geoff Coles May 30, 2024, 03:32 PM

Solely based on rural Zulu politics!

jodyt1981 May 31, 2024, 04:09 PM

Agreed!

louw.nic May 30, 2024, 03:33 PM

Who predicted that the "new dawn" for South Africa after the 2024 Elections would involve Malema, Zuma and McKenzie, with the DA in its perpetual role as bridesmaid / official opposition? Turkeys voting for Christmas, indeed.

xaba May 30, 2024, 04:19 PM

The day we start acknowledging the effect of relative deprivation many blacks have felt since 1994 is the day we will understand politics as a form of job creation. Look how many people are in government today as MPs and councilors for different political parties. The MK will do exactly that, it has created employment for its supporters, some for the first time will be MPs and councilors, a dream that can only be realized by forming and joining a party. We can change this by changing our legislation. Welcome to the MK era, brace yourselves for another Zuma-era and thanks to apartheid and the ANC.

hlavatican May 30, 2024, 05:39 PM

I went to home town to Vote. How enthusiastic people were.. boasting that they are going to vote... they are tired of suffering and they want change. My face brightened up. It was only when I asked who were they going to vote for that I almost fainted. Majority were for MK and others EFF... then I had to ask them what DA... they looked at me like a crazy guy... wondering why I expected them to vote for white people. Now I understand that politics in our country is about Race and Tribe. We just don't trust each other outside the boundaries of race and tribe. I give up!!! If we see Juju, JZ, Gaytone as champions of our cause...

R S May 30, 2024, 07:44 PM

Sad but true.

BillyBumhe May 30, 2024, 07:16 PM

Zulus have always voted only ethnic-tribal lines -- it was only thanks to Zuma that the ANC enjoyed a few brief years of dominance there!

hlavatican May 30, 2024, 08:29 PM

100% It was only after Zuma became DPrez that ANC took over KZN from IFP. Now there is no Zulu person in the echelons of ANC ... they have lost the Province.

marc36 May 30, 2024, 09:31 PM

Those celebrating the collapse of the ANC just got a glimpse of who took their votes, simple as that. Once ANC make a deal with Zuma (which probably involves Cyril resigning) - it'll be ANC business as usual.

niki.higg May 30, 2024, 10:34 PM

What if ANC saw they were losing nationally and knew they would need a coalition and plotted with Zuma, knowing his pull in KZN (i.e. the call to looting in 2021) to start a party that everyone who was disappointed with Anc could vote for and felt tribally fit them. And then after elections "and much consideration" they will form a coalition with MK and get to stay exactly where they are and Zuma gets back in the political ring like he has wanted all along? Why else do you make a party last minute with no real plan, just a face you know will pull votes? Sounds like a win win for them and a lose lose for s.a. and all those people that thought they were sticking it to the ANC fell perfectly into their trap. I can hear Zuma laughing all the way to Luthuli house already.

Kenneth FAKUDE May 30, 2024, 11:48 PM

I like the title of taking MK seriously and it means listening to Zuma very carefully because he talks African heritage which all the parties missed, the danger of people thinking the voters voted along ethnic lines is if it turns out the African cultural identity is at play. Parties that have the potential to lead but never make it must look at this elusive feature that campaign managers miss completely.

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso May 30, 2024, 10:58 PM

I'm just pleased I don't live in KZN. The corruption and murder rate is already off the charts and it certainly isn't going to get better with Zuma at the helm.

William Kelly May 30, 2024, 11:05 PM

So when Zuma shuffles off this mortal coil, MK is done? I don't think so. Those voters aren't going anywhere. So where will they vote? Is kiddie amin playing the long game here, standing by, taking the early hit with the view that sooner rather than later he can merge mk with the eff? I can't see mr flip flopper taking the pain of being up staged and diminished without some attempts to benefit himself from it...

Noelsoyizwap May 30, 2024, 11:07 PM

The three decades long failure of the DA to topple the ANC has brought us to a point where the two parties have come together to rescue. Certainly, the DA on its own, even with MPC, will not be able to achieve this in the foreseeable future. With ANC settling at 42 percent and the DA at 21 percent, as projected by the CSIR earlier this morning in these elections, the two parties have to realize the need to get together to rescue SA. Them coming together is the only option that makes sense. This is also possible because these two parties (a) closer together than with any of the other major parties on the left or right. ((b) To give a fresh start of some sort in the minds of investors and continuation with reconciliation/nation building project of earlier years (c) a two-party coalition will be much better to manage that a collection of a number of small parties, where opportunistic tendencies could also emerge. (d) this could also help the country avoid a clumsy scenes that could come with the death of the ANC.

Alan Jeffrey May 31, 2024, 05:04 AM

100% agree. A grand coalition to recue SA. If the Nats could join the ANC in 1994 then a DA-ANC alliance makes perfect sense. They would also pull in some of the non-looney smaller parties such as COPE, the IFP, ACDP and others. As to the success of MK, it can't all be down to the Zulu factor otherwise the IFP should have done much better as the traditional guardians of Zulu heritage. For me, it can only be that the size of the criminal/uneducated class in KZN is much larger than we thought. I often heard the comment that "How could anybody vote for the ANC " but the vote for Zuma leaves me speechless. The evidence for his wrongdoing, his immorality, his cynical and sinister persona is overwhelming. He literally brought the country and every single human in it to the brink of ruin. Turkeys voting for Christmas just does not describe this madness.

danjingbow May 31, 2024, 11:37 AM

It sounds like a good idea, but will the ANC really take any steps to improve the country? Like, the DA’s main focus in that scenario would be fighting corruption - would the ANC really consent to steps that would put many of its leaders in prison? Also, the DA would come out of this completely broken - like the Nats and the Lib Dems in Britain - the smaller coalition partner suffers the hardest. I think that ANC - DA would only be viable if the DA can can get influential ministerial positions like Finance or Policing. I really think a confidence and supply arrangement will be best - it will prevent the populism associated with the EFF and MK and will ensure that the DA and MPC still has credibility.

Noelsoyizwap May 31, 2024, 12:56 PM

Of course serious sacrifices will have to be made. There is also this call for a national dialogue being made by Thabo Mbeki. I think the country must take this seriously, but because of deep divisions and mistrust, credible international NGOs will have to be involved. This dialogue must lead to a government of national unity.

thomas.adrian.ho May 31, 2024, 11:18 AM

2016 - Zuma - "ANC will rule until Jesus Christ returns!" 2024 - Elections Me - "!!! ... Is this the end of days?"

Noelsoyizwap May 31, 2024, 11:29 AM

Silently, I heard him finishing of that statement by saying "for as long as I have no grievances with the ANC". Light note please....

Jens Eggers Jun 1, 2024, 12:03 PM

The long term sustainability of the MK party will depend on it becoming more than a one-man-show centered on an 82-year-old tribal leader. It's hard to see what substance it has beyond a generic appeal to traditional ethnic values focused on a big man. But who else is there? Where will it be once Zuma has gone?